While the votes are in on her directorial debut film, W.E.—the reviews for the film she directed about Wallis Simpson and Prince Edward are mostly on par with Swept Away—as longtime Madonna fans, we’re still on the fence about her Venice Film Festival Vionnet frock. The pretty pale blue and bright butterflies feel retro and feminine (and are those Miu Miu sunglasses we spy?), but we want to hear your feedback on her film festival fashion: Tell us, do you think her red-carpet look is really rad or just plain bad?