What’s A Good Nail Polish Color For Fall? These Are The Top 5 Shades

Photo: Courtesy of Megan Decker.
Welcome to fall, a season of new energy. We’re shopping for upcoming weddings and holidays, getting haircuts, going back to school or the office full time. When it comes to choosing something as seemingly mundane as a nail polish color for November and December (Scorpio season!), we're being mindful about the tones we're gravitating towards and why — because even more fun than painting your nails is doing it with intention.
Here, our editors and resident nail experts get into the specific shades we're wearing right now and why we think that the tones will resonate this fall. Maybe a naked nail speaks to you like it does me. It could be that you're more of a dark-nail person, in which case, we see you, too. Whatever draws you, we have an IG save and a polish rec for an upcoming manicure.

Bare Nail

Whether you're trying to quit an expensive gel manicure habit or just trying to get your natural nails to a healthier place, the bare-nail manicure is a win. After speaking with a nail dermatologist, I started treating my nail care like my skincare, folding in gentle chemical exfoliation (with glycolic acid), hydration (with cuticle oil), and the right tools (a diamond file). Now, I like my nails almost completely bare — but just with a barely-there gloss.
For a polish, I go for something sheer. Nail artist Jess Brush (@nailbetch) uses one coat of Orly Rose Colored Glasses, which is like the base of a French manicure. I also love two coats of JinSoon Pixie or Essie Mademoiselle.

Black Shimmer

You've heard of the "red nail theory" — the idea that you're more likely to get asked out if you're wearing red nail polish (this is entirely unfounded, btw). This fall, the trend has evolved into the "black nail theory," where black nail polish is said to promote "confidence" while being "bold and daring with a hint of mysteriousness." Plus, it goes with everything.
If you're inspired, consider a glossy black nail polish, like Essie Licorice or Mischo Beauty Run The World. Or, if you want a black polish with a little bit of sparkle, like nail artist Lauren of lolo.nailedit, try Holo Taco in Bat B*tch.

Chocolate Brown

Tones of brown always trend in the fall season. Brown polish is dark and neutral but warmer and more dimensional than black. While it can be tricky to find your perfect shade of brown, nail artist Joelle Rodriguez recommends trying a different tone on each nail and then checking the mirror for the right fit. "A lot of my clients also get up and look in the mirror so they can see themselves wearing the polish, rather than just looking at their hand," Rodriguez explains.
When it comes to brown nail polish, we love OPI Chocolate Moose (a creamy light brown), CND Vinylux in Fedora (a dark chocolate brown), and Côte No. 126 (an earthy brown).

Strawberry Jelly

Something about a jammy red — a strawberry or cherry shade — that feels a little unexpected in the fall. Sure, you'll see the burgundy and red-wine tones, but brighter reds feel fresher. To add something extra, you can sheer our your red polish by mixing it with a clear base or top coat to get a thinner, almost jelly consistency.

Stone Blue

When you bring color theory into nail polish, you can probably guess what a shade of blue is going to evoke: calm. I gravitate towards stone blues in the fall and winter because they break up the monotony of dark shades but also don't feel too bright that it's pastel or neon. Here, I would use Essie Toned Down (this is a gray blue that also looks great on toes), OPI Force of Nailture (a bit darker), or Orly De-Stressed Denim (a mid-wash denim).
At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team, but if you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.

More from Nails

R29 Original Series