I Tested $130 Worth Of Black Eyeliners — & The Cheapest Pick Won

My checklist for eyeliner often feels more exhaustive than the one I have for a partner: Will you stick with me through all my tears? Will you run when I'm having a meltdown? Do you promise you won't go anywhere after we spend more time together? Really?
Scrupulous as it may be (especially considering how I also want my liner packed with jet-black pigment and easily applied with razor-sharp precision), I don't believe in settling. So I decided to test out six different tubes — through thunderstorms, late nights, and more — to find the formulas that live up to all of their promises. All my experiences were fully documented with a bunch of closed-eyes selfies (which is a lot harder than you'd think!) so you can really see each product's wear.
Click through to find out the surprising pick that beat out the rest of the competition.

More from Makeup

R29 Original Series