Following a sold-out performance at Madison Square Garden, the 22-year-old singer rented out a movie theater in Times Square. He and about a dozen friends, including a familiar face — Chantel Jeffries, who Bieber has dated in the past — had the theater all to themselves as they indulged in a private screening. So, what movie did Bieber pick to potentially woo a former flame, and deem worthy of the potential $750 - $3,000 investment? The Secret Life of Pets, of course, TMZ reports. Bieber also shared a picture on Instagram of his feet propped up in an empty theater.