JK Rowling Twitter Snape Harry Potter Son Fan Debate

Photo: MediaPunch/REX Shutterstock

Once again, JK Rowling proved she can hold her own in 140 characters as well as she can in a sprawling novel.

Just as many Harry Potter readers have pondered, a fan asked JK Rowling why the boy wizard named his second son after such a despicable character like Severus Snape. While Harry himself said "[Snape] was probably the bravest man I ever knew," that brief background was unsatisfactory for many, judging by the spirited Twitter debate it sparked.

Snape died for Harry out of love for Lily. Harry paid him tribute in forgiveness and gratitude. https://t.co/MPXBgUApa3
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

With that succinct response, Rowling unwittingly ignited a Twitter-trending Snape debate moderated by the beloved author.

That's not true, I'm afraid. Snape projected his hatred and jealousy of James onto Harry. https://t.co/5jzNHlfSe0
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

She even had to call for order at one point.

Advertisement

Please could we all keep our discussion about this fictional character civil? There's enough rage on Twitter without Snape-related hate.
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

But Rowling's further explanation of Snape's namesake-worthy complexities suggest why Harry honoring him has been a literary decision that's been tough to swallow.

Snape is all grey. You can't make him a saint: he was vindictive & bullying. You can't make him a devil: he died to save the wizarding world
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

And as Rowling pointed out, naming his son Snape was intended to not only pay homage to the Slytherin, but also soothe Potter's own conscience.

In honouring Snape, Harry hoped in his heart that he too would be forgiven. The deaths at the Battle of Hogwarts would haunt Harry forever.
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

As for fans' concerns being soothed once and for all, Rowling has a hunch the debate won't ever be fully settled. But for her part, she's done discussing the matter.

Well, thanks to everyone who participated in today's unplanned debate: "Snape: Good, Evil or What?" People to dinner - got to go! xxx
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) November 27, 2015

For now, at least.

Advertisement

Editors' Picks

Our Editors Won't Wear These Pieces (Feel Free To @ Us)

The Best Black Friday Home Deals, Because Your House Deserves A Present Too

Olivia Harrison

Jackie Aina Is Refinery29's Beauty Innovator Of The Year

More from Books & Art

The Sexiest Books You'll Ever Have The Pleasure Of Reading

A few years ago, people around the world were completely incapacitated by a literary phenomenon. I saw rows of mothers reading the book in chaise lounges

by Elena Nicolaou

The Best Books Of 2018 We Can't Wait To Read This Year

This is how I know I’m reading an incredible book. All of the day’s obligations — making my bed, walking to the subway, cooking dinner — become

by Elena Nicolaou

Michelle Obama Explains Just How Intense Malia's Prom Night ...

“My daughter is being followed by men with guns to prom,” Michele Obama recalls her husband telling her during his presidency. The former First Lady

What To Get The Book Lover In Your Life This Holiday Season

Steps to winning a book-lover's heart: Bring them to a bookstore and actually listen to their book recommendations. Encourage them to accumulate more

by Elena Nicolaou

Get Amped For The Best Books Of November

A curious convergence of fiction and reality happened to me during the Kavanaugh-Ford Senate public hearings in early September. At the time, I was

by Elena Nicolaou

The Poetry Books You Need To Read If You Like Milk & Honey

This weekend, I visited Amazon's brick and mortar bookstore, which is designed to showcase best-selling books front and center, for the first time.

by Elena Nicolaou

What It's Like To Be A Ghost Photographer — & A Top Executiv...

Julie Rieger, the President, Chief Data Strategist, and Head of Media at 20th Century Fox, just wrote a book — but it's not the book you think. Given

by Elena Nicolaou

These Historical Fiction Novels Will Sweep You Away

As it turns out, you don’t need a TARDIS to travel through time. All it takes — pardon our cheesiness — is a library card. But it’s true: More

by Elena Nicolaou

Do Horror Writers Believe In Ghosts? And Other Burning Questions

Steven Crain (Michiel Huisman), the eldest of the Crain siblings in the Netflix show The Haunting of Hill House, needs you to know something: He does not

by Elena Nicolaou

The Best Feminist Books To Spark Your Awakening

So, you want to be a feminist? You've come to the right place. There's no better way to get educated, get angry, get inspired, and get impassioned than by

by Elena Nicolaou

Most Thrilling True Crime Books To Read Before Halloween

True crime is having its moment in pop culture, with everything from cults to scammers making headlines and capturing pop culture through film, TV, or

The More You Know About Busy Philipps, The Better

In the first chapter of Busy Philipps' memoir, This Will Only Hurt A Little, out October 16, she writes about a gross, but exceptionally unexceptional

by Morgan Baila

Watch

R29 Original Series

Film

We helped 12 female directors claim their power.

Comedy

Let's talk about sex, baby.

Documentary

Female artisans around the world

Beauty

Viral trends, tried and tested.

Documentary

From vibrators to lipstick, learn how your favorite products are made.

Documentary

Extraordinary, one-of-a-kind individuals

Documentary

The latest stories to watch.

Lifestyle

Life experiments, 5 days at a time.

Fashion

The style of subculture.

Lifestyle

Inside the homes of millennial women — & what they paid for them

Politics

Made by and for smart, opinionated women.

Documentary

Five love stories behind diverse, multicultural marriages.

Trending Videos

I Traded My Brown Hair For Bright Purple — & This Is What I ...

Dedicated Feature

The Simple Cheesy Dip Recipe You NEED At Your Friendsgiving

Dedicated Feature

Watch R29's Lucie Fink Try 5 Days Of Different Hairstyles

Dedicated Feature

One New Mom's Case For Living In Leggings