We Tried Kylie’s New Lipstick Kits — & Here’s What We Really Think

Welcome to Unfiltered, where we give our honest, no-B.S. reviews of the most buzzed-about beauty products, brands, and services on the market right now.

Before Kylie Cosmetics was a billion-dollar business, it was a small — yet much-discussed — makeup company that specialized in liquid lipstick and lip liner sets known as Lip Kits. After four years, a vast range of products, and retail expansion, the brand has now remixed its OG product duo with a new take that pairs classic matte lipstick and lip liner.

ADVERTISEMENT

In six new shades, the lipstick kit is a good option for Kylie Cosmetics fans who prefer a creamier matte formula in a tube vs. liquid. Given the sell-out status of the originals, we knew we needed to give this launch a try — so we asked a few R29 staffers to put the lipstick kits to the test. Their unfiltered thoughts, ahead.

At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.

I Tried: Fall In Love

The Verdict: "I generally stay away from matte lipsticks because I find them too dry and caky-looking, but I was actually really impressed with this one. It doesn’t look too matte or too dry — it's just a creamy formula that feels pretty smooth on your lips. I like that it comes with a lip liner because it keeps the lipstick from feathering, and I don’t have to search for a match on my own. This more blue-toned shade is perfect for adding a little je ne sais quoi to liven up my work day or vamp up a night out." — Natalie Morin, editorial assistant
Kylie Cosmetics Fall In Love Lipstick Kit$26.00 Buy
I Tried: Girls Trip

The Verdict: "The Kylie Cosmetics liquid lipstick pigment is usually too intense and drying for my everyday routine, so I was excited to try this dialed-down matte lipstick kit out. The color is more orange than the pinks and taupes I gravitate to, but I loved how it looked and felt. I lightly prepped my lips with balm before applying the liner, which glided on seamlessly. On top, I used the matte lipstick, which had a buttery velvet texture that looks blotted and sexy. I was also halfway through a smoothie when this photo was taken and my lip color is still intact, a testament to its staying power." — Aimee Simeon, beauty writer
Kylie Cosmetics Girls Trip Lipstick Kit$26.00 Buy
I Tried: Kylie

The Verdict: "I love a matte lipstick but tend to shy away from liquid formulas, so I was excited to see that Kylie Cosmetics was making its signature lip kits in this format. On my lighter skin tone, the shade showed up as a wearable nude that didn’t wash me out — which is something I am constantly in search of. The liner-lipstick combo definitely made my lips seem plumper and more Kylie-esque (that’s the goal here, right?). I don’t love that the liner has to be sharpened manually, since I seem to have misplaced my sharpener, but that’s kind of a me problem.

"Overall, I dug this formula and especially loved this color — I wore it out to a concert on Saturday, and while it definitely showed up on the rim of my gin & tonic, I didn’t feel like I had to refresh it as much as I do with some other lipsticks. Then, I put it on again for work on Monday and felt just as good. If you're in search of a lipstick that does both, for my money, this is a good place to start." — Cait Munro, senior lifestyle editor 
Kylie Cosmetics Kylie Lipstick Kit$26.00 Buy
ADVERTISEMENT
I Tried: Rendezvous

The Verdict: "As a New Yorker constantly exposed to the cold, I found the original Lip Kit formula too drying for my moisture-lacking lips. Along with the flattering color, this was the perfect matte that didn't dry me out but still delivered in lasting power. I drank my morning coffee, and while the rim had pigment left behind, the lipstick looked untouched when I checked my lips in the mirror. I only applied the product one more time during the day, but even when I removed it once I got home, my lips weren't in desperate need of a balm. I will say that I wasn't a fan of the candy-like smell, but it's easy to get over after three seconds of wear." — Thatiana Diaz, senior beauty writer
Kylie Cosmetics Rendezvous Lipstick Kit$26.00 Buy
I Tried: Koko K

The Verdict: "This is the first Kylie product that I’ve tried, so I didn’t know what to expect. I like how smoothly it applies, and for me it lasted a whole day of being out and about, including all-you-can-eat hot pot. But I think my favorite thing about the lipstick is how it smells like cake." — Whizy Kim, work & money writer
Kylie Cosmetics Koko K Lipstick Kit$26.00 Buy
ADVERTISEMENT
Load more...