When it comes to making clothing wish-lists, we're seasoned vets. Now that we've got our autumn outfits front and center, we can finally focus on our seasonal makeup mood board. To get the scoop on this fall's beauty must-haves, we gathered the top finds from the most sought-after professionals and brands in the biz (Armani! Chanel! CoverGirl!). The result? The ultimate get-pretty guide filled with 12 cool NYC-based makeup artists' lustings—after all, we know what they want, they use; and what they use, we end up wanting. Luckily, dish they did, sharing all the colors, glosses, and creams your heart (and theirs) could ever desire. Plus, you know these finds will soon be spotted on their famous-faced clients.
Click through to find out what's in their beauty basket, and see if you can beat them to the buy!