Best Ice Cream Sandwiches - Delicious Desserts in SF

Skip navigation!

Begin Slideshow

Sure, curses and broomstick rides are nothing but hocus-pocus, but we know one standout way to go ’wich hunting. And, let’s just say what we found is pure magic! The Bay’s tip-top ice-cream sandwiches have us under their spells, and we tried each and every one to determine the best of the creamy confections, narrowing down the field to these 10 stunners.

From a peachy-keen creation at Prospect to a honey-coated crème-fraiche frozen delight at Miette, here are the most decadent sammies to start sinking those chompers into, stat! Find out wich are the absolute cream of the crop, right here! Mmmmmm.

More from Food & Drinks

Mother’s Day Wine Delivery Gifts That Bring The Cheers To Her Doo...

by Elizabeth Buxton

So, How Is It Really? Topo Chico Hard Seltzer

When I think of Topo Chico, I think of sitting at a table outside a trendy restaurant in NYC, enjoying the chillingly refreshing taste of light bubbles. To

We Tried The Viral Onion-Cutting Hack To Save You Some Tears

I can’t tell you if this is scientifically accurate, but: I’m pretty sure I’m genetically predisposed to be extra-sensitive to onion-cutting. I can b

The Best Coffee Subscription Boxes For Stocking Your Kitchen-Cafe

After more than a year (woah) of living, working, existing, et al., almost entirely at home, it’s fair to say we’ve got a few new tricks up the

by Amanda Randone

Found: The Sweetest Online Shops For Ordering Mother’s Day ...

by Brianna Arps

So, How Is It Really? The Incredibly Expensive “Tesla Of St...

To me, fruit has always felt so chic. Perhaps that sounds strange but think about everything a perfectly ripe piece of fruit brings — beautiful bright co

by Olivia Harrison

Why Are People So Disgusted By These Viral Recipes?

In a now-viral video, Anna Rothfuss (or @bananalovesyoutoo on TikTok) shows her followers how to make “honeycomb pasta” using string cheese, Pr

Please Leave Oat Milk Alone

For some reason, oat milk — a pretty innocuous, sustainable dairy alternative that can be found at grocery stores and coffee shops — often ends up embr

You Can Stop Worrying: The Cheese Board Influencer Economy Is Doi...

Picture it: a sprawling array of various meats, cheeses, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and dips meticulously arranged across a large table, surrounded by peopl

by Olivia Harrison

Alcohol & Culture

From Beaver Butt Juice To Fish Bladders, Here’s What’s Really In ...

A few years ago, I was casually sipping on a hard seltzer when I felt my stomach seize. I knew almost immediately that I was having an allergic reaction, s

by Twisha Patni

All The Goods You Need To Make Iced Coffee At Home

by Elizabeth Buxton

All I Want To Do Is Look At Ugly Food Photos

In late January, Olivia Jade made her much-anticipated return to YouTube following the 2019 college admissions scandal. I devoured the entirety of her firs

by Olivia Harrison

R29 Original Series