Best Ice Cream Sandwiches - Delicious Desserts in SF

Skip navigation!

Begin Slideshow

Sure, curses and broomstick rides are nothing but hocus-pocus, but we know one standout way to go ’wich hunting. And, let’s just say what we found is pure magic! The Bay’s tip-top ice-cream sandwiches have us under their spells, and we tried each and every one to determine the best of the creamy confections, narrowing down the field to these 10 stunners.

From a peachy-keen creation at Prospect to a honey-coated crème-fraiche frozen delight at Miette, here are the most decadent sammies to start sinking those chompers into, stat! Find out wich are the absolute cream of the crop, right here! Mmmmmm.

More from Food & Drinks

The Best Non-Alcoholic Drinks For Dry January Sipping (& Beyond)

by Olivia Harrison

20 Unique Advent Calendars You’ll Want To Gift Everyone (& ...

How Brazilian Women Challenged Slavery and Patriarchy Through Food

In the quaint district of Milho Verde, it’s impossible to go without hearing about Geralda Francisca dos Santos and her biscoito de polvilho (a cassava f

by Beatriz Miranda

Valentine's Day

The 27 Best Online Bakeries With The Sweetest Valentine’s D...

by Brianna Arps

20 Valentine’s Gifts Under $25 That Are Seriously Crush-Worthy

by Victoria Montalti

We Found The Best Meal Delivery Service Deals So You Don’t ...

At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the ed

by Alexandra Polk

Finding Out I’m Celiac Means Longing For The Foods I’ve Lost

When Kirsten Roberston, 27, found out she had celiac disease six years ago, she decided to indulge in one final gluten-loaded meal. “It was my last suppe

by Tanyel Mustafa

As a Xicanx Vegan, I’m Dismantling a Cruel & Racist Food Sy...

Growing up in Texas in the 1970s, I spent long periods away from my mother. My parents divorced when I was 4 years old, so my mom raised my sisters and me

by Lauren T. Ornelas...

With A Bow 2023

5 Best Wine Advent Calendars For Spreading Holiday “Cheers!...

Advent calendar culture is flourishing. From classic chocolate truffles to luxury skincare, adorable cat toys, and more — you can count down the holidays

by Alexandra Polk

We Found The Best Gifts For Tea Lovers — & Scored Readers A Deal ...

Super Sale Alert: Get 20% off sitewide at Vahdam Teas using our promo code R29VAHDAMHOLIDAY, now through November 30. When in doubt about what to buy fo

by Victoria Montalti

Get A Head Start On Holiday Shopping With This BOGO Deal For Cura...

The holidays are approaching, and it’s almost time to think about what to give the special people in your life. That may be good news if gift-giving is y

by Victoria Montalti

I Tried The Ember Mug, The Stanley Girl’s Answer To Hot Gir...

My morning doesn’t start until I whip up a fresh cup of matcha (not the latte, nor the sweetened kind you get at Starbucks — just plain, straight-u

by Karina Hoshikawa