Yes, This Is Us Has Fan Theories, & They'll All Make You Cry

Photo: Courtesy of NBC.
On the surface, NBC's new hit This Is Us is just a cuddly family drama, replete with Thanksgiving spats, teachable moments, and loving embraces. Under the saccharine surface, though, the show is riddled with mystery. Granted, it's no Westworld, but This Is Us has its fair share of gasp-inducing moments and riddles that have yet to be unfurled.

Most of the mystery in the show derives from the dual story lines. One narrative follows Jack and Rebecca, parents to a scrappy set of triplets. The other narrative follows those same triplets, all grown up. As we learn about the increasingly fractured Pearson family, we must piece together the intervening 30 some-odd years that separate the two timelines. As such, the show has invited the type of fan theorizing one usually sees with thrillers and mysteries.

Mainly, everyone wants to know: What happened to Jack Pearson? Jack, played by Milo Ventimiglia, is the patriarch of the Pearson family until, well, he's not. In the "modern day" story line, which focuses on the children, Jack isn't around. In his stead, his best friend Miguel serves as a pseudo father. (Miguel is presumably married to Rebecca in the modern story, and none of the kids seem happy about it.)

Ahead, you'll find the most intriguing theories about the Pearson family, dredged from the depths of the internet. Be forewarned: Most theorize about Jack Pearson's status, which the show will allegedly address in next week's episode.
1 of 4
Photo: Courtesy of NBC.
Jack Dies Of Addiction
In the early episodes, Jack Pearson shows himself to have an alcohol problem. Many redditors have speculated that this will eventually lead to Jack's death. This theory also assumes that Jack dies while still married to Rebecca.

And, if you're wondering, he's definitely dead. Viewers of the show will recall that Kate has his ashes in an urn.
2 of 4
Photo: Courtesy of NBC.
Randall's Father William Will Die In The Same Episode As Jack
Okay, not in the same story lines. But, as ScreenerTV points out, it's likely the show will address both deaths in the same episode. William rejected chemotherapy which means, unless a miracle occurs, death is imminent. And Jack, well, you know. As This Is Us isn't one to shy away from tear-jerking, it's likely the show will give us a double whammy shortly.
3 of 4
Photo: Courtesy of NBC.
There's Another Kid
Bear with me. In the trailer for the 13th episode, Jack asks Rebecca, "What if we had another kid?"

Yeah, Jack, what if? It seems far-fetched, but what if Jack isn't actually dead — not super likely, I'll admit — and is in fact living in Bermuda with another child somewhere? At the very least, it would be an opportunity to introduce another important character in the coming seasons. (The show has already been renewed for two more.)
4 of 4
Like this post? There's more. Get tons of celebrity news, fun takes on pop culture, and trending stories on the Refinery29 Entertainment Facebook page. Like us on Facebook — we'll see you there!

More from TV


R29 Original Series