Update: Criticism of Gwyneth Paltrow’s sunscreen application reached a fever pitch yesterday, with celebrity skin experts like Caroline Hirons, Renée Rouleau, and Sofie Pavitt taking to social media to call out the "technique" seen in the Vogue video. In a statement sent to Refinery29 via email Wednesday night, goop claims that Paltrow did, in fact, apply sunscreen to her entire face in the full video, which the brand says was edited for length.
"In the Vogue video, Gwyneth applies sunscreen to her entire face, though the video is edited down for timing’s sake and does not show the full application," the statement reads. "Her comment specifically says she does not ‘slather it head to toe’ over her entire body but she addresses the importance of sun protection and mineral sunscreen, which deflects rays off of your skin, rather than absorbing them, as chemical sunscreens do. We’re huge proponents of SPF at goop and always advise that people should consult their dermatologists to find out what is right for them.” Vogue has yet to address any of the alleged editing of the video.
This story was originally published on March 31.
While the products Paltrow gravitates to aren't surprising or problematic, the way she's using one of them in particular has sparked serious backlash. The actress and wellness CEO's flippant approach to sunscreen — she dabs it only on her nose and cheeks ("where the sun really hits") — has earned criticism from skin experts and hundreds of YouTube commenters, as has the terminology she uses when talking about "clean" beauty.
Yesterday, anonymous beauty collective Estée Laundry shared a critique of Paltrow's tutorial on Instagram, with a screenshot of the video's thumbnail. "Gwyneth Paltrow using SPF like highlighter and slathering moisturiser on top, while repeating misleading buzzwords like 'clean beauty,'" reads the commentary along with the eye-roll emoji.
NYC-based esthetician and certified acne specialist Sofie Pavitt also responded, advising people not to apply sunscreen like Paltrow. "Please, for the love of God, don't apply SPF like highlighter," she warns followers in an Instagram Story stitched over the Vogue tutorial. "SPF should be the non-negotiable for any preventative skin-care routine if you don't want to prematurely age, or get, you know, skin cancer."
Beyond Paltrow's incorrect sunscreen application, Pavitt adds that viewers should be aware that there's no FDA regulation on marketing terms like "non-toxic" and "clean," which the Goop founder uses repeatedly throughout her tutorial. "When brands heavily promote their 'clean,' 'vegan,' 'chemical free, 'natural,' paraben free,' non toxic,' skin-care lines [it] make[s] my eyes roll back into my head," Pavitt wrote in a followup post. She then added her own advice for people shopping for skin-care products: "You should buy a product because it's good, not because you've been scared into doing so," she says. Any sunscreen you don't mind applying — and reapplying — to your entire face falls firmly under the category of "good."