Botox. Should you, or shouldn’t you? Everyone’s got an opinion on it. Tabloids still love to point the finger of judgement at any famous woman who appears to be defying time, just as much as they love to decry those who dare to leave their lines and wrinkles untouched.
Botox gets a hard time. Ask aesthetic doctors or clinic owners what the most popular treatment on their menu is and they pretty much unanimously say Botox. It gets unrivalled results when it comes to smoothing out lines and wrinkles on the forehead and around the eyes. It’s widely-considered safe – a study published in 2014 in U.S. medical journal JAMA Dermatology found an average of one negative side effect for every 3,333 Botox procedures. Plus, because it’s a prescription-only medicine, it’s more tightly regulated than, say, dermal fillers or laser treatments.
But is spending a few hundred dollars on injections to make wrinkles disappear when you’re in your 20s pointless, or good skin sense? And more importantly, is it, eventually, going to make you look worse?
“If I buy a Ferrari and hammer it, I’m not going to go to the garage 10 years later and say, ‘I’ve never had it serviced or valeted, can you sort it out?’” says Dr Askari Townshend, founder of aesthetic clinic Askinology.
“Whether or not you can see there’s a problem with your Ferrari, you take it to the garage on a regular basis so they can keep it in tip-top condition, so in 10 years’ time, you still have a beautiful car. That’s the same with your skin. A little bit all the way through is how you keep things looking good.”
Dr Townshend is an advocate of having Botox preventatively; he says it’s like giving a leather jacket a break to let the creases drop out. But not everyone agrees with this approach.
“I don’t really believe in having preventative toxin treatments,” says Dr Maryam Zamani of The Clinic By Maryam Zamani, who specialises in ophthalmology. Like many doctors in the “No” camp of having Botox young, Dr Zamani says starting too early is at best a waste of money and at worst, ultimately going to make you look older. “A lot of people start in their 20s as a mechanism to ward off getting lines and wrinkles caused by movement. But in reality, a lot of people in their 20s don’t have any of those lines yet. It usually starts in your 30s.”
I see some ladies who are 23, 25, and they’ve been smoking for 10 years and using sun beds, so they’re very different to somebody who’s 35 who’s looked after themselves.
What age you are when you start to get lines and wrinkles is a bit of a “how long is a piece of string” question; everyone’s skin ages at different rates and it depends on your skin type, race, genetics and lifestyle. Dr Townshend says, “I see some ladies who are 23, 25, and they’ve been smoking for 10 years and using sun beds, so they’re very different to somebody who’s 35 who’s looked after themselves.”
“You have to treat what you see in front of you, not the patient’s age,” says Dr Sarah Tonks, from Omniya clinic in Knightsbridge. She says that if you’ve got a “hypermobile” face (that’s lots of smiling, frowning, raised eyebrows and WTF faces) she’d consider treating in the 20s to stave off lines and wrinkles. “But, if they don’t have anything, and they don’t have hypermobile muscles, then there’s no point in doing it,” she adds.
Dr Jonquille Chantrey, who runs Expert Aesthetics in Cheshire, agrees that she’d treat someone with a hyperactive face with Botox earlier — the earliest she says is around 28 — but she also says that your expression lines are part of who you are, and not necessarily something you should try to hide.
“It depends on where on the face the lines are. If they’re part of the person, like an attractive part of their expression, then I usually say to leave it a little bit longer,” she says. “And for me, I don’t think that smile lines are a particularly negative thing, if those other factors have been considered and managed.”
But does getting started too early actually make things worse in the long run? Dr Zamani says yes. She says paralysing the muscles in your brow or around your eyes will, over time, cause them to atrophy (that’s the medical term for when a muscle withers from under use — think what an arm looks like when you have a cast removed after a broken bone). Smaller facial muscles means less volume in the complexion, which is another sign of skin ageing.
Dr Townshend doesn’t think that’s a reasonable argument though, partly because the muscles in the face are so tiny that if they do shrink a bit, no one’s going to notice. “I don’t buy into this idea that I could walk down the street and say, ‘That lady’s got an atrophied forehead,’” he says.
However, Dr Chantrey says she’s seeing problems with younger patients who’ve had their foreheads over-injected. “What I’m seeing is their brows are starting to drop earlier than would be normal for them. If you’re overly injecting [the horizontal forehead lines], it compromises the brow position, so it does give you a slight brow heaviness, potentially.”
And there’s the risk of a similar problem if you have too much Botox injected around the crow’s feet too young. “If the smile lines are treated aggressively too early, it can flatten off the sides of the eyes; it can give a more unnatural smile,”she says. And although the effects of too much too young are reversible, Dr Chantrey says it can take time — longer than the three to four months it takes your Botox to wear off.
There are of course other ways you can “service” – to use Dr Townshend’s analogy – your face in your 20s without injectables. A good skincare regime that’s high in antioxidants like vitamins A and C, plus daily SPF is a starting point – and topical treatments like peels that are rich in alpha-hydroxy acids can help reduce the appearance of early fine lines.
Of course, no one needs to have Botox. And if you do choose to have a little work done to smooth out some lines, then great. But when it comes to getting it done early, there’s more to consider than just the cost.
Dr Chantrey’s parting piece of advice to me: “If it’s just purely cosmetic in patients under 25, when it really is quite minimal, early [signs of] ageing, then I really don’t think it’s a great habit to be getting into. That’s how I feel about it.”