Under-$20 Secret Santa Gifts Everyone Will Want To Steal

Unless you have that perfect peach candle Emma Stone crooned about on SNL, finding the right Secret Santa gift is, frankly, a pain in the ass. It needs to fall within a certain price range, please every last person in the group, and be available at a moment's notice. Personally, we think the answer here is booze, but not everyone shares our sentiment.

So, we rounded up tons of unexpected beauty gifts that are sure to be stolen first. Ahead you'll find quirky, cute, cool, and even practical options that work for every gift exchange you'll be attending — and they start at only $5.
1 of 28
Under $5

Yes, this is a terrycloth headband that makes you look like a kitten while you wash your face. Great for: cat people you like. Even better for: dog people you don't like.

Etude House Cat Headband, $5, available at Memebox.
2 of 28
This tiger face mask will make an Instagram appearance before the party ends, guaranteed.

SNP Animal Tiger Wrinkle Mask, $5, available at Ulta Beauty.
3 of 28
Under $10

Photo prop turned relaxing bath soak? You'll be the party favorite.

Lush The Magic of Christmas, $8.95, available at Lush.
4 of 28
Because sheet masks are even better in a storybook set...

TonyMoly Shea Sheet Mask Box Set, $7.50, available at Ulta Beauty.
5 of 28
A delightfully random banana keychain is great on its own; even better when it comes packed with moisturizing lip balm.

TonyMoly Banana Lip Balm, $10, available at Ulta Beauty.
6 of 28
Under $15

This crowdpleaser is a safe bet that feels substantial and festive.

Essie 4-pc. Holiday 2016 Nail Polish Gift Set, $12.99, available at Kohl's.
7 of 28
Chill vibes are inevitable with this bath soak. Bonus? Chic and modern packaging makes it gift-worthy.

Cedar + Stone Scrub, $12, available at Urban Outfitters.
8 of 28
Is there anything more to say here than, "Cuuute"?

Too Cool for School Max in Pocket Lip Balm, $12, available at Sephora.
9 of 28
This cheek-and-lip-stain duo will please even the non-makeup wearers in your group.

Peripera Peri’s Tint Water, $12, available at Birchbox.
10 of 28
Especially great for the morning after your office party.

Drybar Capsule Mornings Blow Coffee Mug Limited Edition, $14.50, available at Nordstrom.
11 of 28
Chic and simple, this clip elevates Monday mornings and Saturday nights.

Kitsch Pony Holder Clip, $12, available at ShopBop.
12 of 28
This best seller from Jen Atkin's line was made for your Kardashian-obsessed colleague.

Ouai Wave Spray Travel, $12, available at Ouai Haircare.
13 of 28
Not for the beauty shy — but so damn cool.

Berrisom Oops! My Lip Tint, $15, available at Birchbox.
14 of 28
Fragrances are tough to give acquaintances, but pretty much everyone can agree on these.

Tocca Spice Rollerball Collection, $15, available at Sephora.
15 of 28
Hand lotion may not be the most inventive gift, but it's always appreciated. And this duo is especially luxurious.

Korres Greek Body Butters On the Go, $15, available at Sephora.
16 of 28
Under $20

Again: Cuuute!

ColourPop Mama's Apple Pie Shadows & Pigments, $18, available at ColourPop.
17 of 28
A foolproof pick for your boss — and oh-so-fancy.

Deborah Lippmann Ice Queen Nail Polish Set, $17, available at Sephora.
18 of 28
This scent kit is perfect for the leather jacket-wearing, too-cool-for-school girl in your circle... Or every single person in your circle, if you divvy it up right.

État Libre d'Orange Eau de Parfum Discovery Set, $19, available at Sephora.
19 of 28
You can pop your makeup sponge into this adorable, Fendi-looking fur pouch. Or, use it as a coin purse or pill box.

Sephora Collection Studley Sponge and Travel Case Set, $18, available at Sephora.
20 of 28
Prepare to have this white-elephant gift meet the "three steals allowed" maximum quite quickly.

Kat Von D The Bow N Arrow Set, $20, available at Sephora.
21 of 28
Wait, no, this one might actually go first...

Make Up For Ever Artistic Smoky Eye Kit, $16 (originally $20), available at Sephora.
22 of 28
For the Pinterest fanatic. 'Nuff said.

Armed & Readi I’m Not Perfect, But My Eyebrows Are Pouch, $19.99, available at Armed & Readi.
23 of 28
For the Gemini in the group: one vial is sexy and sultry, the other bright and floral.

TokyoMilk Dark Femme Fatale Collection Fragrance Duo, $18, available at Sephora.
24 of 28
This gel liner is makeup artist Patrick Ta's go-to for his signature cat-eye. And it looks good on everyone.

Tarte Gallery Gals Deluxe Tarteist Eyeliner Set, $19, available at Sephora.
25 of 28
Your coworkers will love this luxe perfume set.

Aerin Travel Matchbox Gift Set, $20, available at Sephora.
26 of 28
Forget Secret Santa — this belongs in your own desk drawer.

Smith's Rose Bud Tin Set, $16, available at Urban Outfitters.
27 of 28
You know that coworker who always keeps a face mist on their desk? They'll love this re-up.

Plantfolk Apothecary Moon Water, $18, available at Urban Outfitters.
28 of 28