30 Gorgeous Engagement Rings We Found On Etsy

Photo: Courtesy of Etsy.
Shopping for an engagement ring takes a lot more planning than, say, picking up another pair of underwear (at least, we hope it does). After all, nobody wants a symbol of undying love that they only feel meh about.

Price-point panic aside, the most intimidating part of scoping out rings is all the options. Do you want certified vintage, or contemporary? Diamond or emerald? Does a traditional ring design fit your personality, or do you want to get creative? On Etsy, there are no limitations to what's available to shop — just looking at them all can be dizzying. So, we've done the paring-down and weeding-out for you, pinpointing 26 stunning engagement rings that will make saying "yes" a no-brainer.
1 of 30
Victorian jewelry is all about symbolism: What better way to start your lives together than with the union of two different, but equally beautiful, stones?
2 of 30
We'll go to infinity and beyond wearing this band.
3 of 30
A classic setting featuring an unconventional, black-gold band.
4 of 30
This vintage ring transcends centuries: While the royal-blue band dates back to 1820, the diamond was added sometime after 1930.
5 of 30
Etsy hosts a wealth of vintage jewelry: This ring dates back to sometime between 1900 and 1909, during the height of the Edwardian era.
6 of 30
Stacking rings are a trend that translates beautifully into engagement jewelry.
7 of 30
This ring checks off on the socially-conscious list; it's made in an eco-friendly studio using socially responsible materials, and 10% of sales go to charity.
8 of 30
The perfect ring doesn't have to be fussy: This mixed-metal style gets it just right.
9 of 30
Something beautiful to look down at on your big day, and every day.
10 of 30
Diamonds take the backseat on this ring, where they crown a pear-shaped emerald.
11 of 30
A Victorian-era ring fit for a queen.
12 of 30
Minimalists can want diamonds, too.
13 of 30
The geometric setting makes room for even more sparkle.
14 of 30
The "Toi et Moi" style represents two souls coming together, a symbol that dates back to Napoleon Bonaparte (and his then-fiancée, Josephine).
15 of 30
Between the Marquis-cut diamond and the delicate, white-gold band, there's a lot to love about this ring.
16 of 30
One for your betrothed, and one for you. (Or, both for you — you can sort that out yourselves.)
17 of 30
The contrast between the rough-cut diamond and the pavé band is pure beauty.
18 of 30
A blue sapphire steals the spotlight on this slithery diamond ring.
19 of 30
Everything's coming up roses.
20 of 30
In addition to gorgeous jewelry, this Etsy shop boasts that all of its materials are "recycled, eco-friendly, environmentally safe and sustainable, and ethically mined."
21 of 30
Behind the diamond-encrusted yellow sapphire, this ring boasts a tiny heart silhouette — a constant reminder of what it's really all about.
22 of 30
Embrace a woodland-themed wedding right from the get-go.
23 of 30
The setting for this Herkimer diamond is playful, and it puts the gorgeous stone (an affordable option compared to real-deal diamonds) on display.
24 of 30
The silhouette of this ring is unique, yet classic enough that you'll wear it for years to come.
25 of 30
This made-to-order ring is set with a ruby, but can be designed with any stone you choose.
26 of 30
A sculptural, sterling-silver ring is perfect for the girl who shies away from sparkle; the blue sapphire adds just enough glimmer.
27 of 30
Vintage-lovers will be tickled pink, er, blue by this diamond-and-sapphire ring from the 1930s.
28 of 30
Boasting conflict-free diamonds, this minimal style is a winner in more ways than one.
29 of 30
Originating in the 1910s, the gold band of this vintage ring makes a nice backdrop for the center's yellow diamond.
30 of 30
Not everyone's first preference is diamonds.