Why Calling This Hairstyle "Twisted Mini-Buns" Is Offensive

Photo: MCV Photo.
Cultural appropriation. It’s a term we come across more often than we'd like to in the beauty and fashion industries. Because, no matter how many times designers, brands, and publications get called out on it, it's still happening. Be it the co-opting of cornrows and babyhairs, or trying to pass off big butts as a new phenomenon, the industry has a way of picking aspects of different cultures and passing them off as its own.

Just last week, hair blog Mane Addicts wrote a post about the "twisted mini-bun" hairstyle seen on models at the Marc by Marc Jacobs spring 2015 show. At first glance, one might not see a problem with the "buns" sent down the runway. Except, they originated in Africa, have been worn by women of color for centuries, and go by the name Bantu knots. Understandably, the Internet went off in response to the post. It has since been taken down.

There's no problem with borrowing hairstyles from other cultures. The issue lies in the dismissal of history and context. It lies in repackaging a style as “chic” and a “new trend” when worn by white women, without any credit to the culture it was taken from — by either the stylist who created it or the editors reporting on it. This is where the distinction between celebrating a culture and appropriating it becomes fuzzy.

“I’m 50/50 on it, because I think they take [these styles] because they love it; they’re so intrigued and they want to put [them] out there. But, not only won’t they give us credit, they won’t educate themselves,” says celebrity hairstylist Ursula Stephen, who's worked with Rihanna, Mary J. Blige, and Kerry Washington. “They take it and capitalize on it. Have I ever gotten a call to do a runway show? No, but I see the models walking down the runway with all of the styles I’ve done on Rihanna. It’s funny: We’ve come a long way, but we still have a ways to go.”

Until we better equip our industry leaders with information so that they can speak to, say, the history of dreadlocks or the origins and cultural significance of cornrows — or, even better, diversify the talent and hire individuals who are already armed with this knowledge — we'll continue to face situations like the Zendaya and Giuliana Rancic "weed" controversy and people associating cornrows with being in "jail."

“When we have more of our brown girls on the red carpet, like Rihanna wearing Bantu knots and doobies and things from our culture, that helps to break it down a little bit and lets people know that a lot of things they’re wearing or doing are a part of our natural culture,” says Stephen.

The industry needs to give credit where credit is due — or the same women its leaders are “inspired” by will continue to feel neglected and excluded from the conversation.


Like this post? There's more. Get tons of beauty tips, tutorials, and news on the Refinery29 Beauty Facebook page!
Photo: MCV Photo.
Advertisement

More from Hair

After a long summer of hot sun, chlorine, and salt water, your strands may not be looking their best. That's why fall is the perfect time for a hair ...
We'd be lying if we said our desktops, Pinterest boards, and Instagram explore pages weren't loaded with hair porn. While we like stalking our friends' ...
In the past few years, we’ve witnessed the launch of silent hair dryers and damage-free bleaching. We’ve learned that shampoo comes after conditioner, and ...
Looks like the PLL star is trying to soak in all of the fun as a blonde. Her hairstylist, Kristin Ess, posted a picture on Instagram of the actress ...
Think about your most expensive possession. You probably treat it with the utmost care, making sure to keep it away from anything that may cause it damage...
Can I get an amen for air-drying? For those of us who lack the time, energy, or desire to repeatedly shoot a concentrated stream of scorching hot air on ...
Blowdryers are essential. (Not in the way that food, water, and shelter are, but you know what we mean...) And essentials just aren't that sexy. Add the ...
Our hair loves the idea of summertime. Beachy waves! Golden highlights! Braids on braids on braids! But unfortunately, summertime doesn’t always love our ...
The curly-hair market has been booming lately. New natural hair brands are popping up left and right, while "mainstream" lines are adding more products and...
Over the past few years, the tousled beach-wave look has proven to be much more than a passing trend. It’s a hairstyle with staying power, possibly on its ...
As you well know, we love drugstore products here at R29. Which isn't to say that prestige products are overrated. But finding a balance between high and ...
In a perfect world, we’d all have plenty of money to splurge on high-end products for each and every hair need. (Ditto skin and makeup.) And in a really ...
Sure, the lob may be the reigning cool-girl cut. And you may have a few friends who are snipping their strands into impossibly chic pixies. But that doesn'...
While the summer may have some beauty benefits (hello, dewy skin!), it can seem like a crapshoot for your hair. From protecting your color to maintaining ...