Time to get real: Hershey's Kisses-filled candy canes, Russell Stover teddy bears, and other drugstore-bought offerings do not qualify as holiday gifts — even for a Secret Santa exchange. The good news? There are scores of far more treasure-worthy goodies that are just as affordable and convenient as any drugstore score. In fact, 12 of them are just a click away. Here, we've gathered our favorite under-$25 picks perfect for every gift-swap participant, from the makeup addict to the serial-selfie-taker (click through and you'll get it, promise). Happy Santa-ing!