Unless you want to be that person who shows up to dinner with carnations and a heart-shaped box of chocolate, you need a thoughtful, one-of-a-kind gift to show your No. 1 you really care. (If you want your relationship to last through the night, that is). But, that doesn't mean grabbing your glue gun and a bag of sequins like you did when you were 7. All it takes is a quick browse through Etsy to find those special, handmade-feeling gifts. To make it even easier for you (we know, there's a lot of choices on there), we rounded up 35 of our favorite presents for you ahead. Click through to find the one your other half will love almost as much as they love you. Almost.
Like this post? There's more. Get tons of style secrets, insider shopping dish, fashion news, and more on the Refinery29 Fashion Facebook page!