How Your Fitness Tracker Is Underestimating You

Photographed by Rockie Nolan.
If you feel like your FitBit doesn't give you enough credit, you might be onto something. According to new research, several popular fitness trackers underestimate just how hard we work.

For the study, published in May in PLOS One, researchers had 22 participants test four fitness trackers with the ability to measure your heart rate. The trackers included the Apple Watch, FitBit Charge HR, Mio Alpha, and the Samsung Gear S. Each participant came to the lab for initial measurements (e.g. height, weight, and oxygen intake) and then returned two more times for hour-long testing sessions.

The testing involved running on a treadmill and indoor cycling interspersed with periods of rest. While each participant had his or her performance measured with one of the fitness trackers, the researchers also monitored heart rate and energy expenditure (calories burned) using lab equipment. Throughout the testing, each participant ended up wearing every device.

Results showed that contrary to some previous findings, all the devices were pretty accurate when it came to heart rate. But the trackers weren't so good at estimating how much energy you were putting out — with up to a 43% error rate.

It turned out that they actually underestimated how hard the participants were working. Although the Apple Watch was the most accurate at estimating heart rate, it was the least accurate at calculating energy expenditure. On the other hand, the FitBit was least accurate at heart rate and the Samsung Gear S was the most accurate for calories. However, no tracker was consistently more or less accurate than the others overall.

If your tracker is reminding you to stay active and motivating you to keep going, that's a good thing — even if it's not an exact measurement of what you're up to. And as this study shows, you might even be working harder than you think.

More from Fitness

Sometimes getting motivated to exercise can be harder than the workout itself. That’s why it helps to think of your gym time as a middle school dance: ...
The benefits of yoga are constantly touted by fitness gurus and scientific researchers alike: practicing yoga has been linked to reducing stress, boosting ...
Working out's a LOT more fun when you can do it on your own terms, in your own crib, with your own tunes, and your own friends
When it comes to rock climbing, an all-or-nothing approach is key
Ashley Graham is breaking barriers. She's the first plus-sized model to cover the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue and she's served as our workout ...
In a move so fitting that we can’t believe we haven’t seen it already, ASOS teamed up with running shoe company Saucony to create glitter running ...
If you ask us, no workout is complete without a killer playlist — and running is no exception. Whether you prefer the trails or the treadmill, the right ...
(Paid Content) Normally, we celebrate getting into a fitness groove. It means that we've committed — on a pretty regular basis — to laying out workout ...
We may not all be able to keep up a daily diet of personal training, SoulCycle, and hot yoga. But there's a lot more to learn from celebrities' workout ...
Update: This story was previously published on Nov 21, 2015. Are you sitting down? Okay, take a minute to assess: Are you slouching in your seat? Are your...
Ah, the plank. Some version of it is used in virtually every type of fitness program, from CrossFit to calisthenics to yoga to pilates, and for good reason...
A new study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association has found that fitness trackers aren't exactly the key to a super-healthy ...
Maybe you're someone who appreciates the sturdiness of genuine leather. Perhaps you can't stand the idea of going to an hour-long vinyasa class without ...
Hailey Langland is a 16-year-old snowboarding star who believes that if you're not having fun doing something, it's not worth doing. "What sets me ...