Can Livestreams Ever Replace Front-Row Seats At NYFW?

UowzeQDnwUEsD2SRijo5TTNE6Lx4OBgqhTtmRji3L9Q-1
We all know a seat in the front row at NYFW is a boatload of fun — the atmosphere, the celebrities, the sense of overwhelming superiority just can't be beat. But when it comes to the clothes, is there really a difference between seeing it up close and in person and watching a 360 view from the comforts of your laptop? Well, as Suzy Menkes writes in The New York Times today, the digital experience is not only frustrating, but fundamentally lacking.
Advertisement
Fashion shows do, after all, serve a purpose: It's a chance for buyers and editors to predict (or perhaps select is the right word) what's going to work for shoppers and readers. As much as designing clothing is an art, there will always be a craft aspect to it, because these things are designed to be worn. In this field, there can be no beauty without functionality. So, when Menkes, or any other editor or buyer, must resort to a digital livestream, a crucial part of that curatorial process is lost. She writes, "I still felt uneasy about the difficulty of analyzing fabrics, recognizing true colors and allowing my own eyes to follow the pieces that interested me." It's that last bit that really gets us. When you're watching on a screen, you'll see whatever comes in front of you, and keep looking for the next chapter, hoping not to miss something. When you're really there, it's a completely different story. If something is really good, you won't care about the next look, because your eye will follow it as it twists and turns through the audience, down the runway, and you'll wait for it to make a second appearance in the final lineup.
This problem actually has a very real application in everyday life, too. Even in NYC, we rely on online shopping more and more for convenience, not to mention in the name of a great deal. But we've all been through the frustration of purchasing something that looked positively dreamy online, only to find it's a not-so-hot mess upon unwrapping a week and a half later.
The complaint that life online is taking away our taste for the real thing is a common one — and maybe a valid one. When it comes to Fashion Week, an editor's lament of settling for an online livestream instead of her traditional front-row privilege due to weather conditions is in danger of sounding snooty. Suzy Menkes is a presence at any and every major show, she's got access to fashion most of us can only dream about, a front-row seat to designs that cost more than the average rent — but she has a point. While we appreciate the effort to bring access to the masses, this is one area where this first rung of exclusivity holds real, if eventual, value for the everyday consumer. Just as a G-Chat conversation can't compare to a face-to-face, heart-to-heart, front-view "blog fodder" and low-res livestreams can't compare with the swish and sway (or intentional lack thereof) that make good design great, not just on a magazine page but on your inherently non-digital body.
Advertisement

More from Designers

Carlton Banks, your moment as a fashion icon has come. On Wednesday, Miuccia Prada showed a collection that, at first glance, might not immediately remind ...
While other luxury heritage brands are sticking to what they know (meaning the dated, one-season-out showing), Burberry is keeping up with the times — and ...
Since taking the helm at Gucci at the beginning of 2015, designer Alessandro Michele has singlehandedly transformed the fashion industry. He (like ...
Sewing, cutting, draping, steaming — though you might not know how to do these things yourself, you’d recognize most of the processes of creating an ...
You don't have to raise your hand if you're among the people who choose to take a break from Instagram during Fashion Week; we know you're out there, and ...
Last February, we were treated to a crayon-colored, upbeat disco for Ashish's, fall 2016 presentation. This season, however, Ashish Gupta took a more ...
I have been working in the fashion industry for just over eight years now, but I’ve spent the majority of my life being big. Even in my wildest fashion ...
(Paid Content) Last week, Thakoon left convention behind when he presented his new collection at a scenic waterfront setting in Brooklyn, perfectly timed ...
J.W. Anderson's intimate show for spring/summer 2017 wasn't one for claustrophobes. The front (and only) row in a tightly-packed, vibrant green corridor ...
It's almost a running joke in fashion that the most universally disliked shoes can (and do) make unexpected, sweeping comebacks. Case in point: The Ugg x...
After the models stormed the catwalk, '80s super style, for the finale of the Topshop Unique show, editors, buyers, and A-listers shuffled toward the door...
In a Fashion Month with many established brands attempting to revive their houses via designer switch-ups and step-downs (and some labels just opting out ...
To the masses, Michael Kors' best-sellers may be handbags and ballet flats. And that's fine; it's how one builds a billion-dollar fashion empire. But each ...
Athleisure has taken many forms as it's flourished over the past few years. You can wear a sports bra designed by your favorite celebrity, like, say, ...