Please upgrade your browser for the best Refinery29 experience. Read more.
Another day, another light wintry mix. It seems that Mother Nature's been nursing a serious Four Loko habit judging by our inadequacy to walk out the door with a weather ensemble that doesn't have us saying "FML." So, can you blame us for turning to something we know will stay consistent? The concept is so pure and simple, and yet, on a freezing cold afternoon in February, this timeless combo is the only thing that really hits the sweet spot. We're talking about milk and cookies, duh—with some warm chocolate goodness and a cold glass of milk, our playing-in-the-sandbox memories come flooding in, and all of a sudden, we just feel so darn warm and cozy! To feed your insatiable sweet tooth and to soften up that icy cold city heart, we've scoured NYC for the best places (and an at-home recipe!) to score the tastiest milk and cookies available this side of the black market, from the tried-and-true classic to a minty number prime for spring. Somewhere, the Keebler Elves are jealous.
Click through to make your stomach growl!