1. Inexpensive: Filippo Berio Pure Olive Oil, 750 ml (25 ounces), $10.99 at GourmetItalian.com (known as Tigre Pure Olive Oil on the West Coast).
For high-heat cooking, chefs don’t use extra virgin olive oil. They use the pure stuff, which is actually a mix of refined and virgin olive oils. Pure olive oil has a higher smoking point, more neutral flavor, and reasonable price tag. “It also makes great mayonnaise,” says Samin Nosrat, a San Francisco Bay Area chef, writer, and cooking instructor, and a subject in Michael Pollan’s Cooked. Nosrat makes her mayo with two-thirds pure olive oil and one-third good extra virgin olive oil.
2. Won't Break The Bank: Frantoia Extra-Virgin Olive Oil, 1 liter (33.8 ounces), $29.99 at Murray’s Cheese.
When it comes to off-the-heat cooking, Frantoia is my go-to olive oil, and one of the best deals around. It’s a beautiful Sicilian extra-virgin choice that’s fruity and herbaceous with a hint of pepper and almond on the finish. I use it for vinaigrettes, salsa verde, pesto, gelato, even cakes. Nosrat explains, “If I’m going to say it’s an olive oil ‘something,’ I use the good stuff.”
3. The Splurge: Santa Chiara by Costa dei Rosmarini, 750 ml (25.3 ounces), $32.95 at TaylorsMarket.com.
Top-of-the-line oils are too pricey to cook with. They’re meant to be used sparingly as a seasoning — on soups, salads, crostini, you name it. “My very favorite olive oil is Ligurian — Santa Chiara, Costa dei Rosmarini” says Nosrat. “It’s buttery and less spicy. And, I love that it comes wrapped in a gold." Of course, the taste is most important here, but as with our other high-low pairings, good looks don't hurt.