NYC's Best Spots For A Low-Key After-Hours

Tired of the same ol' restaurants and watering holes? We totally get it. Even in a city as huge as New York, your go-tos can start to feel pretty — well, gone-to. So, we're here to help you shake up your after-hours routine.
From sleek uptown Manhattan to the gritty streets of Brooklyn, we'll show you our favorite hidden gems, brand-spanking new hotspots, and neighborhood faves worth traveling for. And, we'll show you the coolest outfits to help you fit right in (and standout).
Advertisement
So, urban adventurers, click on the link below to explore Refinery29's massive guide to the best new nightlife! Trust us, you don't want to make your Friday night reservations without this.
1 of 15
Bed frames on the ceiling, mid-century bubble lamps, and graffiti shouldn’t work, but somehow, they all come together beautifully at The Fourth. The new restaurant from the husband-wife team behind Tocqueville and 15 East serves next-level brasserie fare that’s so rustic, its menu is divided into sections titled “livestock” and “starch.” We’ll take two of each, please!

On the style front, try a turquoise top and royal-purple pencil skirt for a combination that’s a fitting union of upscale and unpretentious.

The Fourth, 132 Fourth Avenue (at E. 13th St.); 212-432-1324.

Prabal Gurung Printed Silk Crepe De Chine Shirt, $1,250, available at Net-A-Porter; Minuet Petite Bright Purple Pencil Skirt, $122.98, available at House of Fraser; Gianvito Rossi Two-Tone Leather and Suede Pumps, $705, available at Net-A-Porter; Illamasqua Lipstick in Eurydice, $24, available at Sephora; Kelly Wearstler Pavlov Ring, $295, available at Kelly Wearstler; Need Supply Co. Margot Bag, $36.99, available at Need Supply Co. (currently out of stock).

Photo: Courtesy of Angela Hadl.
2 of 15
The cocktail bar adjacent to eternally hot Momofuku Ssäm raises mixology to high art. The drink menu can change multiple times a night. Wear something cute and colorful with a liberal dose of whimsy. Then belly up to the bar, and ask the bartender to make you something with flames or liquid nitrogen. They’re the drinks of the future, today!

Booker & Dax, 207 Second Ave (at E. 13th St.); 212-254-3500.

Rebecca Taylor Summer Blazer, $325, available at Rebecca Taylor; Chance New SS T-Shirt, $72, available at Chance; Sass + Bide Trust But Verify Fitted Mini Skirt, $290, available at Sass + Bide; Clare Vivier Duffle, $300, available at Clare Vivier (currently out of stock); Prada Platform Oxford, $379, available at Barneys; Illesteva Leonard Sunglasses, $170, available at Opening Ceremony.

Photo: Courtesy of Gabriele Stabile.
3 of 15
The gastropub goes haute cuisine. Unpretentious comfort food and amazing desserts from wd~50's Wylie Dufresne make this the perfect dinner-date spot. Wear an outfit that’s as clean and graphic as the white-brick walls, and definitely try the root-beer pudding — if only we could order that stuff by the gallon.

Alder, 157 Second Ave. (between E. Ninth and E. 10th streets); 212-539-1900.

Acne Bird Print Exploded Sweatshirt, $250, available at Acne; T By Alexander Wang Viscose Crepe Shorts, $195, available at La Garconne; Jeffrey Campbell Melina Cutout Ankle Boot, $160, available at Urban Outfitters; French Connection Wild Horses Clutch, $108, available at French Connection; Club Monaco Lunar Stacking Ring, $49.50, available at Club Monaco.

Photo: Courtesy of Jaeger Sloan.
4 of 15
Manhattan’s newest It cuisine? Georgian food! This low-key spot on Avenue B serves up a whole new land of intricately spiced shish kebabs, slow-cooked lamb, and dumplings to explore. Trust us — it’s a beautiful thing.

Fashion-wise, think casual, simple separates that nod to the restaurant’s Alphabet City roots. Now, tuck into that canoe-sized, stuffed cheese bread like it’s your last day in Tbilisi.

Oda House, 76 Avenue B (between E. Fifth and E. Sixth streets); 212-353-3838.

H&M Jersey Top, $4.95, available at H&M; Uniqlo Ankle Length Pants, $19.90, available at Uniqlo (currently out of stock); Solo Sandals, $165, available at Yoox; BCBG Allie Whip-Stitch Satchel, $228, available at BCBG; Marni Earrings, $360, available at The Corner.

Photographed by Sara Haile.
Advertisement
5 of 15
These days, speakeasy-style cocktail bars are as common as egg whites in a pisco sour. We love this Billyburg newcomer, though, because it has all the inventive, quirky cocktails, but none of the vintage pretensions.

Follow suit in this ultramodern take on a sweatshirt and flats — after all, comfort’s key when queuing up for your third Hemingway daiquiri.

OTB, 141 Broadway (between Driggs Ave. and S. Sixth St.); 347-763-1481.

Tibi Transit Structured Sweatshirt, $345, available at Tibi; Rebecca Taylor Sateen Color Block Trousers, $177, available at Rebecca Taylor; BCBG Barlowe Satchel, $328, available at BCBG; Steve Madden Vamp Faux-Fur Flats, $75, available at Macy's; Etienne Aigner Double Block Ring In African Jade And Pyrite, $75, available at Etienne Aigner.

Photographed by Sara Haile.
6 of 15
Better than Luger’s? Yep, better than Luger’s. Ever since New York magazine named St. Anselm’s $15 hanger steak the best in the city, you’re lucky if you can get a seat at this unassuming steakhouse. But when you finally sit down to your perfectly grilled hunk of hanger, you’ll believe.

Stylewise, casual-cool is the name of the game — and we definitely recommend shorts if you end up seated next to the grill on an 80-degree day.

St. Anselm, 355 Metropolitan Avenue (between N. Fourth and Havemeyer streets); 718-384-5054.

A.P.C. 70s Jacquard Tunisian Top, $97.50, available at A.P.C.; Surface To Air Denim Shorts, $78, available at The Corner; Keds Champion Polka Dot Lace, $40, available at Keds; Rockland Backpack, $84, available at Need Supply Co. (currently out of stock); The Row Acetate Circle Sunglasses, $336.25, available at Eyewear Concierge; Revlon Just Bitten Kissable Balm Stain, $8.99, available at Revlon.

Photo: Courtesy of St. Anselm.
7 of 15
Of the many things Eastern Europeans do well, pierogies, sausage, and beer are probably nearest to our hearts. You can get all three at Kristophe, the new warm and rustic spot from Krzysztof Drzewiecki (better known for his beloved Polish restaurant, Krolewskie Jadlo, in Greenpoint).

A low-key look matches the room’s sultry wine-cellar vibe, and the oversized sweater — while not strictly required — leaves all the more room for schnitzel.

Kristophe, 221 N. Fourth Street (between Havemeyer and Roebling streets); 718-302-5100.

Urban Outfitters Mesh-Brim Snapback Hat, $19.99, available at Urban Outfitters; Acne Deep Wool Jumper Dress, $320, available at My Wardrobe; Dorothy Perkins Bailey Dark Indigo Superskinny Jeans, $44, available at Dorothy Perkins; Miista Shona Gold Heeled Gladiator Sandals, $227.83, available at ASOS (currently out of stock); Dior Vernis Nail Lacquer in Purple Mix, $24, available at Sephora.

Photo: Courtesy of Kristophe.
8 of 15
With its black-leather club chairs, low-lit vibe, and truly impressive selection of Scotch and craft beers, Isle of Skye is like the library of a whiskey-swilling sophisticate — and that’s a good thing in our book.

Give a nod to the British Isles in this modern fisherman sweater (made 10 times more fun with a graphic mini and bright tote), and see if you can luck into one of Isle’s free whiskey tastings.

Isle of Skye, 488 Driggs Avenue (between N. Ninth and N. 10th streets); 347-384-2772.

Peter Jensen Chunky Geelong Pullover, $343, available at La Garconne; Tibi Multicolor Transit Skirt, $275, available at Tibi; Topshop Notion Cross Over Mid Sandals, $156, available at Topshop; Modcloth Apricot Tote Bag, $59.99, available at Modcloth (currently out of stock); Kenneth Jay Lane Resin Bangle, $44.99, available at 6pm.

Photo: Courtesy of Andrew Zimmer.
9 of 15
If Gwyneth ever deigned to visit Bushwick (as if), we think she’d be pretty enamored by Fitzcarraldo. The new venture from Henry Rich and Julian Brizzi, owners of Boerum Hill’s much-loved Rucola, gives local ingredients a Northern Italian twist. Think chilled fava-and-mint soup, ramps with smoked-almond pesto, and downright life-changing breakfast pastries.

The food may be peasant-inspired, but the dining room is patterned after a crumbling opera house in a Werner Herzog film. So, we think a little sartorial grandeur is called for — such as Three Floor’s delicate lace-overlay dress, a sleek gold cuff, and a clutch with major pop.

Fitzcarraldo, 195 Morgan Avenue (between Meadow and Stagg streets); 718-233-2566.

Three Floor Shades of Blue Dress, $261.53, available at Three Floor; Topshop Ratchet Block Strappy Heels, $77.83, available at Topshop; Vince Camuto Cutout Cuff Bracelet, $148, available at Vince Camuto; Proenza Schouler Small Lunch Bag Gradient Clutch, $1,450, available at Luisaviaroma; Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils Babydoll, $30, available at Sephora.

Photo: Courtesy of Nina Westervelt.
Advertisement
10 of 15
In keeping with the neighborhood, Miles is a no-frills, laid-back place to chat up your bartender while getting a stiff, perfectly mixed drink and a small plate. If you need more convincing, we have four words for you: free mac and cheese. Every Monday, from 6 to 8 p.m. Did Miles just shoot to the top of your to-try list, or what?

Also in keeping with the neighborhood, the crowd is model-off-duty cool. Try a chic, striped top and a pencil skirt in beyond-comfy jersey fabric, and settle in for that Tuesday-night, bring-your-own-records dance party.

Miles, 101 Wilson Ave (between Troutman and Starr streets); 718-483-9172.

Jacquemus Cropped Top, $123, available at La Garconne; Cameo Rose Black Textured Midi Skirt, $12.45, available at New Look; Jil Sander Navy Lace-Up Oxford, $349.99, available at Gravity Pope; Jil Sander Navy Backpack And Fanny Pack, $625, available at Yoox; Movado Bold Mid-Size Watch, $595, available at Movado.

Photo: Courtesy of Travis Dubreuil.
11 of 15
Boisterous, welcoming, and always packed, Peaches is down-home Southern cooking…if your mama made an unearthly good blackened catfish with grits and the best chicken wings this side of Buffalo, that is.

The crowd at Peaches is as unpretentious as the chow, but the look is definitely colorful and subtly dressed to impress. A shrunken sweater and sporty miniskirt make you the chicest thing chomping on a shrimp po’ boy.

Peaches, 393 Lewis Ave (at MacDonough St.); 718-942-4162.



J.Crew Collection Cashmere Fair Isle Back-Zip Sweater, $298, available at J.Crew; Uniqlo Cotton Mini Skirt, $9.90, available at Uniqlo; Modcloth Deep Sea Vibe Necklace, $21.99, available at Modcloth; Alice + Olivia Dina Cherry Blossom Pumps, $206.50, available at Shopbop (currently out of stock).

Photographed by Sara Haile.
12 of 15
Together with its few-doors-down neighbor, Do or Dine, this brand new bar is making Bed-Stuy a destination for late-night sip seekers. The byword at Dynaco is “warm” — cozy, vintage-sourced booths and an insanely good chocolate cake make this a divey date spot par excellence.

What to wear to your new neighborhood go-to? Try something clean and sporty that does double-duty — in case a table at Do or Dine ever opens up. And if it doesn’t, Dynaco’s expertly curated beer list makes a pretty great consolation prize.

Dynaco, 1112 Bedford Ave (between Gates and Lexington avenues).

H&M Checkerboard Top, $24.95, available at H&M; Stella McCartney Bedford Fluid Trousers, $443, available at Matches Fashion; Steven By Steve Madden Anibell Pumps, $109.95, available at Amazon; BaubleBar Lucite Garden Drops, $28, available at BaubleBar; Clare Vivier Foldover Clutch, $210, available at Clare Vivier; Essie Bond With Whomever, $8, available at Essie.

Photographed by Sara Haile.
13 of 15
If you’re used to bustling, scene-y bars in Manhattan, this beyond-chill spot is a welcome relief. 67 Orange also boasts expertly seasoned small plates (get the Parmesan fries!) and one of the city’s few female mixologists.

Jeans and a T-shirt are definitely the way to go here. Now go ahead, grab an Earl Grey-infused gin cocktail, and make yourself at home.

67 Orange Street, 2082 Frederick Douglass Boulevard (at W. 113th St.); 212-662-2030.



Prabal Gurung All Over Flower Tee, $250, available at Kirna Zabete; American Eagle Jegging Ankle, $49.95, available at American Eagle; Jeffrey Campbell National Block-Heel Leather Bootie, $205, available at Neiman Marcus; H&M Straw Hat, $12.95, available at H&M; Sophie Hulme Burgundy Mini Envelope Leather Clutch, $459.23, available at Liberty London.

Photo: Courtesy of 67 Orange Street.
14 of 15
This Harlem hotspot is always hopping. An open-late kitchen and one of the biggest and best courtyards in the city make it a great place to grab an after-hours bite — may we recommend the buttermilk fried chicken?

Harlem Tavern, 2153 Frederick Douglass Boulevard (at W. 116th St.); 212-866-4500.



Marc by Marc Jacobs Rae Interlock Dress, $348, available at Marc Jacobs; Madison Harding Magda Wedge Pumps, $257, available at Shopbop; IIIBeCa by Joy Gryson Duane Street Crossbody, $158, available at Bloomingdale's; Etienne Aigner Hinged Bracelet, $55, available at Etienne Aigner (currently out of stock); Givenchy Le Vernis Intense Color Nail Lacquer in Croisiere Purple, $20, available at Sephora.

Photo: Courtesy of Harlem Tavern.
15 of 15
A dressed-to-impress crowd, a massive drink menu, and brunch that’s truly worth the wait makes Corner Social Harlem’s hippest destination.

If you do hit it up, keep yourself comfy in a denim-on-denim outfit that’s equal parts chic and comfy. And consider yourself warned — the cornflake-crusted French toast might just ruin all other breakfast foods for you, forever.

Corner Social, 321 Lenox Avenue (at W. 126th St.); 212-510-8552.

Topshop Moto Floral Crop Denim Shirt, $35, available at Topshop (currently out of stock); H&M Slim Regular Jeans, $29.95, available at H&M; Rebecca Minkoff MortySandal, $109.79, available at Bluefly; Modcloth Azure Bet Bag, $62.99, available at Modcloth; J.Crew Stone Mix Necklace, $135, available at J.Crew.

Photo: Courtesy of Corner Social.
Advertisement