Is Steven Avery Guilty? Former Fiancée & Making A Murderer Directors Weigh In

Nobody can stop talking about Making a Murderer. Whether it’s a rap song or a failed quest for a presidential pardon, Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey have become overnight superstars in the fight for exoneration. The documentary series advanced a fairly comprehensive case that Avery and Dassey were not given fair trials, and that seems to be the prevailing sentiment among most of its viewers.

So it should come as no surprise that when series creators Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos sat down with Stephen Colbert on Tuesday, that they would continue in that line of argument.

Colbert asked the question on everybody’s mind: Is Steven Avery guilty?

"I mean, my personal opinion is that the state did not meet its burden either in Steven Avery's case or Brendan Dassey's case," Ricciardi told him. "So I would say, in my opinion, not guilty."

"I mean there are things that he could be guilty, but is he guilty beyond a reasonable doubt? Nothing I've seen, and I've seen a lot of stuff, nothing I've seen has convinced me of that," Demos said.

Advertisement

But Avery’s ex-fiancee Jodi Stachowski has a very different perspective on things. In an interview with Nancy Grace producer Natisha Lance, Stachowski dropped a bombshell.

“What do you want people to know?” Lance asked.

“The truth,” Stachowski said.

“Which is?”

“What a monster he is. And he’s not innocent.”

That seems like a pretty unequivocal statement from someone that’s as close to Avery as can be. Stachowski went on to say that she had received letters from Avery while he was incarcerated — the two have broken up — of which she’s opened only one. That letter was filled with threats.

"I ate two boxes of rat poison just so I could go the hospital… and get away from him, and ask them to get the police to help me," she told Lance.

Her response to whether or not she ever loved Avery was similarly unequivocal: “No.”

The full interview, which represents Stachowski’s first public statements since the docuseries was released, will air Wednesday night at 8 PM on HLN.
Advertisement

More from TV

Everything about Luke Cage communicates strength. The burly Harlem resident seems patient and unfeeling. Bullets can’t wound Luke Cage, and knives can’t ...
Try as we may to separate the man from his work, it feels disingenuous to write about a Woody Allen project without so much as mentioning the personal ...
A major network has just ordered a series about a man who sends for a mail-order bride from the Philippines and winds up with a full mail-order family. ...
The 2016 Emmy Awards were off to a great start when a surprising announcement came over the loudspeaker. A voiceover announced the next presenter: none ...
Julianne Hough has responded to Amber Rose's accusations that the dancer body-shamed Rose on Dancing With the Stars. Hough told Entertainment Tonight that ...
Every once in a while, a show comes along that we're super psyched about — and not just like, "This is a cool series you should consider watching," but ...
Every Wednesday, the Johnson family enters millions of living rooms across America. Dad Andre brings the laughs with his stubborn-but-silly antics, which...
Kimmy Schmidt lives in her own world. It's a cross between middle school, the year 1999, and present-day New York. Mix in the fact that she was held ...
Grey's Anatomy is back, and it's kicking off this week's episode with a Hamilton reference. Well, kind of. Technically, when Webber offers to be Bailey's...
We know what you're thinking: Gee, I really could use more Kardashian-Jenner-West coverage on TV. Just kidding. The only people who think that are E! ...
Amazing news, TV lovers of the world: Since we first published this story in 2013, there have been leaps and bounds in the number of streaming platforms ...
We're less than two months away from the Netflix premiere of Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life on November 25. In the meantime, Rory and Lorelai thought ...
Two episodes into the third season of How To Get Away With Murder, we're one step closer to finding out who dies in the fire at Annalise's (Viola Davis) ...
We've written extensively about how all the American Horror Story seasons are linked. But we didn't realize that Roanoke would be the Rosetta Stone through...