"100 Years Of Beauty" Responds To Viral-Video Criticism

Last week, we stumbled upon a gorgeous, yet haunting video showing glimpses into women's lives throughout the years. Karolina Żebrowska produced the piece in response to Cut Video's viral "100 Years of Beauty" series.

"I felt that the other videos were completely unrealistic and there was a sense of fakeness that really irritated me," Żebrowska told us.

But Żebrowska's videos had some problems as well — as commenters pointed out. For example, utilizing one (white) woman meant only one representation of womanhood, despite the lofty goal of showcasing reality. And today, Christopher Chan, visual anthropologist at Cut, wrote a post on Medium defending "100 Years of Beauty."

"There’s a troubling logic behind [Żebrowska's] video and the praise it has been receiving. The trouble’s not in attempting to pay homage to the bravery, strength, or fortitude from women in history," Chan writes. "It’s in the assumption that any one representation of a woman can be more 'real' than another. And we must be very critical of the selection criteria altogether."

Chan goes on to explain Cut Video's process of researching the specific eras through ads, propaganda, and popular media. He also speaks to showcasing the behind-the-scenes of every look, created with makeup and hair products. And yes, he even acknowledges that Cut looks are representations of history, almost fantasies. They're not realistic.

"Here’s the problem with history: It’s not real. It’s not the past. It’s a representation of the past," he writes. "It’s remembered, through documents and oral histories and photographs, but somebody does the work of choosing which of these fragments make it into the narrative. It’s just as staged as the cover of Elle, and it leaves out more than it can include."

Still, that doesn't mean we can't learn from these representations — and it doesn't invalidate Żebrowska's point, either. Popular fashion and beauty styles are often visually identified with popular sentiments of the time, like the '50s-housewife aesthetic, and representative of particular symbols in history (or herstory, if you prefer).

"I think we learn something very interesting about history by visually documenting its fantasies: We see how race, citizenship, class, and sexuality are moving targets that are constantly being policed — and that these categories are never stable or safe," Chan writes. Oftentimes, Cut Video looks reference political and social situations (see: its depiction of Korean beauty trends through the years — although that received criticism for fluffy depictions of North Korea).

Perhaps the bigger question isn't about "who is a real woman" — obviously everyone who identifies as a woman is a real woman. The question is about whether it's okay to appreciate beauty styles from a distance — without knowing the full stories of the women who wore them.

More from Beauty

How does one of the most wealthy, famous, and beautiful people alive (see: People) celebrate her 44th birthday? If you’re Gwyneth Paltrow, Hollywood’s ...
Prepare to go wild with clasped-hand emoji, because we’ve got big news: Urban Decay is adding another fluorescent-filled eye shadow palette to its roster...
We’ve seen our fair share of unexpected celeb ink these past few weeks — like Bella Thorne’s kitty tat or Frances Bean’s halloween art. But swimming semen...
When I was eight years old, I knew nothing about makeup. Did that stop me from collecting palette upon palette of colorful shadows and sparkly tubes of ...
If our fascination with Rob Kardashian as a blonde last week proves anything, it's that we can't get enough of radical hair transformations. The latest ...
I just signed up to the @YGAP @polishedman campaign! One in five children fall victim to physical and/or sexual violence, before they turn 18. That’s ...
We love watching behind-the-scenes montages from celebrity photo shoots. From the dream locations and racks of gorgeous clothing, to endearing, off-the-...
(Paid Content) If achieving clear, glowing, incredible skin were as easy as slathering on a single cream, we’d be the first in line to scoop it up. But ...
In the grand scheme of new beauty-product releases, nail polish is, undoubtedly, the most overwhelming. The top brands flood the market with several ...
Foundations: It's likely there are more bottles than faces for them to cover. And, while all those choices may seem to make your decision easier when ...
When a beauty editor with access to a hundred variations of every product you could dream up cuts open a tube or sticks a Q-tip into a bottle just to get ...
When you hear “3-D printing,” you probably don't immediately think of lipstick. But that's about to change because the latest cutting-edge launch from ...
No-makeup makeup is no longer just a fleeting trend — it's one of the biggest beauty staples, and it’s not going anywhere soon. So, of course, there’s a ...
As beauty editors, one of the top questions we're asked on the regular is actually pretty basic: "What should my skin-care routine look like?" And it makes...