Why Wasn't Michael Dunn Convicted Of Murder?

dunnPhoto: Courtesy of Jacksonville Sheriff's Office.
There's no question that Michael Dunn killed 17-year-old Jordan Davis when he opened fire on him and a carful of his friends in a Florida parking lot in 2012. And, yet, on Saturday, a Florida jury did the logically impossible: It found Dunn guilty of attempted murder, but it could not reach a verdict on the death for which he is unquestionably responsible.
Advertisement
Maybe the backstory could clear things up.
Two years ago, Dunn, a white 47-year-old software developer, and his fiancée, Rhonda Rouer, pulled up to a Jacksonville gas station convenience store, and parked near a Dodge Durango that held Davis and three of his friends, who are black. The car began blasting loud music. "I hate that thug music," Dunn allegedly said. When Rouer went inside the store, a confrontation occurred; Dunn claims he politely asked the young men to turn down the music, but that they shouted expletives at him and threatened him with a shotgun.
At that point, Dunn leaned over to his glove box, unholstered his 9mm pistol and loaded the chamber. (In an interview with police, Dunn claims that he had practiced the maneuver at a gun range, and that he was "an avid gun guy.") Dunn fired a total of 10 times, continuing to shoot as the car pulled out of the parking lot. Davis was hit three times and died shortly after.
When Rouer exited the store, Dunn simply told her to get in the car and took her to the hotel at which they were staying. He didn't call the police or 911, and he didn't tell Rouer anything about the young men having a shotgun — which, by the way, the young men claimed did not exist, and the police never found.
Firing a gun into a car full of teenagers apparently constitutes second-degree attempted murder in Florida, where jurors found Dunn guilty of three counts for which he could face up to 60 years in prison. Justice, in that case, has been served. The jury couldn't come to a decision on the first-degree murder charge, however, and the judge declared a mistrial on that count, which means Dunn will see yet another courtroom.
Advertisement
But, even if Dunn's actions didn't meet all of the qualifications of first-degree murder, the jury also remained deadlocked on lesser charges — including second-degree murder, manslaughter, and justifiable homicide — that were automatically included with the first-degree murder charge.
As The Daily Beast's Jamelle Bouie puts it, "If Dunn had killed Davis and his friends — or if he had killed Davis without shooting afterwards — then, by to the logic of the jury, he would have escaped punishment altogether."
The case has naturally drawn comparison to the killing of Trayvon Martin as well as a discussion of Florida's controversial "Stand Your Ground" law. Critics have frequently claimed that Stand Your Ground had nothing to do with George Zimmerman's defense, but this is simply not true. Ditto in this case, as Dunn's lawyer, Cory Stroll, was explicit in his closing argument: "His honor will further tell you that if Michael Dunn was not engaged in an unlawful activity and was attacked in a public place where he had a legal right to be....He had no duty to retreat and had the right to stand his ground and meet force with force, including deadly force."
With that invoked, the prosecution had to prove to the jury that Dunn was not acting in self-defense. And, yet, despite his highly suspicious story — the lack of a gun in the Durango, the fact that he didn't call the police or give his fiancée the full story — the jurors simply could not be convinced.
Advertisement

More from Politics

The day after the debate, instead of shifting away from the issue, the GOP nominee doubled down on his weight-shaming comments. And on Friday, he took the ...
Election Day lasts just one day — a 24-hour culmination of the seemingly never-ending campaign season. But we’ll spend the next two, four, six years ...
GOP front-runner Donald Trump has gotten a lot of flak for some of the ridiculous statements he's made this campaign season, including that women who seek ...
If the chaotic party politics of the 2016 election have left you feeling completely birdbrained, this video is for you. The Founding Fathers (presented ...
Ebling has been by her friend's side through marriages, births, deaths — all the ups and downs of life. But she never expected her old playmate to be just ...
1. Major News: One person died in a Hoboken, NJ, train crash and more than 100 were injured. A commuter train crash on Thursday morning injured more ...
The Final Five are national treasures. They're basically a collection of perfect, perfectly happy humans. And who wouldn't be, especially after turning in ...
Throughout history, Americans have used activism as a tool to seek positive change in communities and in government. That's no different today. With ...
1. Here At Home: A teenager killed his father before opening fire at a school in South Carolina where he wounded two students and a teacher. ...
California passed a law Wednesday removing the state's 10-year statute of limitations for filing of child molestation and rape charges. Governor Jerry ...
Monday night was the personification of media bias and rigged politics
If you had to describe the current political climate in America, what word would you choose: volatile, toxic, or divisive? Perhaps all of the above. ...
Hillary Clinton has been a role model for our generation for years, and now she’s laying out a master class in taking on workplace sexism
1. Major News: A bill to prevent the government from shutting down and to fund the fight against Zika was stalled in the Senate. With a 45-55 vote, the...