So, What's The Deal With That Other Bangladesh Accord?

Gap and Wal-Mart are no strangers to labor-rights controversies — both retailers have routinely come under fire for being involved in sweatshop labor and human rights violations. After the devastating Bangladesh factory collapse tragedies, many U.S. and international retailers signed onto a legally binding factory accord, but Gap and Wal-Mart maintained that they disagreed with parts of the IndustriALL-led and would create their own. Their plan to do things differently is obviously worrying many human and labor-rights groups, but Gap and Wal-Mart will be forced to defend their own plans before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in Congress this Thursday.
John Lubbe, the key defender of the new accord, put their main grievances with the InsutriaALL-led accord in four parts.
Advertisement
Firstly, he stated that "the accord requires a five-year commitment from participating retailers to conduct independent safety inspections of factories and pay up to $500,000 per year toward operational costs. A majority of U.S. retailers have stated they would not be able to sign the accord because of significant legal liability concerns."
Secondly, Lubbe maintains that the IndustriALL-led accord puts too much of the regulatory onus, including inspections, on the retailers, not the government. He argues, "While the U.S. retailers are prepared to contribute in a variety of ways to improving worker and building safety standards in Bangladesh, the primary regulatory and enforcement function of such standards remains under the auspices of the Bangladeshi government."
Thirdly, retailers that operate within one factory operation will be forced to work together in the event that a factory closes, must lay off its workers, or needs repairs.
And finally, Lubbe argues that arbitration and other legal activities that will undoubtedly come out of the IndustriALL accord will drive up the prices of its products.
It seems like the bulk of the concerns lay in creating more legal responsibility and checks for big brands than they're used to…which might not be a bad thing if the consequences are a reduction in worker deaths, inhumane labor conditions, and unstable local economies. And if we consumers have to pay a few pennies more for our tees…we hope we aren't being presumptuous in saying that that's a fair price for clean fashion. (WWD)
Advertisement
Photo: Courtesy of News.com.au
bangladesh
Advertisement

More from Events

My Little Ponies are objectively fashionable. They come in every outfit possible, from a fairy to a goddam pirate, and have inspired many a dye job. So, it...
We’ve all heard the story: Fashion Week has changed, almost beyond recognition. From a closed-door, industry-insider event to all-access areas and ...
Fashion collaborations come and go, but this New York Fashion Week, none caught editors' attentions quite like the one between the New York City ...
While everyone heads across the pond for Paris Fashion Week, we're still reeling from the display of ogle-worthy garments that made it down the runways in ...
Legendary fashion photographer Bill Cunningham passed away on June 25 this year, which means this is the first New York Fashion Week without him. ...
At the second day of New York Fashion Week: Men’s shows, attendees were greeted with a powerful political message before taking their seats or perusing a...
This story was originally published on September 4, 2014. Anna Wintour once said, "We all get dressed for Bill." And, why wouldn't we? It’s no secret ...
(Paid content) September — or, as many of us lovingly call it, fashion month — is right around the corner. And thanks to the never-ending stream of ...
There was them and there was us: “Them” being the guests of the Chanel Cruise 2017 show and “us” being the crowd of Cubans and camera-toting foreigners ...
It's been a busy few days for the fashion elite. On Sunday night, there was the glamorous occasion of President Obama's final White House Correspondents...
Hollywood hit the Hilton in Washington, D.C., Saturday night for the 2016 White House Correspondents' Dinner. The annual tradition has become a hot ticket ...
Among the more than 200 pieces that make up the latest blockbuster exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, Undressed: A Brief History of ...
There’s no denying that plus-size women and plus-size fashion have experienced a surge of popularity recently, so it’s not completely surprising that one ...
I’ve been working in the fashion industry for more than eight years, and the changes I’ve seen over that course of time have been remarkable; I’ve gone ...