Reprehensible: A Hollywood Trainer Publicly Nitpicks Former Child Stars

As anyone who's ever seen True Hollywood Story knows, the life of a former child star isn't always a fairy tale —  even if you manage to stay away from drug scandals, nude photos, and career-killing roles. But, to add insult to injury, one of Hollywood's most famous personal trainers is now picking apart their bodies, scrutinizing the eating and exercise habits of (his words, definitely not ours) "the fit (and not so fit) former Disney stars." Wait, what?
Harley Pasternak, who's worked with celebrities such as Jessica Simpson and Hilary Duff, is a highly in-demand personal trainer. He's also a blogger for People.com, where he's now opining on the bodies of former child stars, from Miley Cyrus to Raven-Symoné. And while he focuses mainly on stars who he sees as fit, he also includes a few who, as he put it, "opted to 'fill out' rather than work out." Our hackles? Oh, they're raised, all right.
Trainer_embed
Ashley Tisdale, one of Pasternak's clients, wins praise for eating just one solid meal (along with two smoothies) per day. Another client, Hilary Duff, earns plaudits for her yoga and pilates regimen. But, the trainer isn't so kind to stars who he doesn't personally work with. He's "skeptical" of Christina Aguilera's hard-fought acceptance of her body: "While she's definitely not grossly overweight, she doesn't look comfortable in her own skin like she did once upon a time." As for Britney Spears? "She's not working out as much as she once was." Pasternak goes on and on, but we'll stop there, because quite frankly, we're not interested in spreading that kind of body-shaming negativity any further.
That said, it's still worth taking a look at what's happening here. And precisely why we think it's so troubling.
Eleven hundred words. That's how long Pasternak spends critiquing the bodies of these women — some of whom have histories of mental illness, self-harm, drug abuse, or eating disorders. Some are mothers whose bodies have changed after having children, and others still are barely out of their teens. Instead of focusing on their skills and accomplishments — or their struggles and challenges — Pasternak judges these women by their bodies alone. And he's essentially holding up one single standard of beauty as the one we should all be aspiring to — without even a nod to the breadth and diversity of body types (and ages) that make up the reality of women's beauty.
But, what's most frustrating about his piece is that it feels so unsurprising. Implying that women's bodies are "good" or "bad" (and we all know that's code for "skinny" and "fat") has become a depressingly predictable way to talk about women.
Predictable, maybe, but not popular. Judging by People.com readers' comments, it's clear we weren't alone in finding Pasternak's post distasteful, and last night he tweeted an apology. "In no way, shape or form do I think that a woman's value is determined by her weight," he wrote. "I was not commenting on these women's worth. ... I understand the objection that some of you had that I commented on women that have never been clients of mine, and I can't help but agree. We all know, as a nation, we're out of shape, and my job is to help people be the healthiest versions of themselves through diet and exercise. But we're also a nation fighting eating disorders and body image issues, and I should be more sensitive to both issues. Please accept my apologies."
We're still not crazy about the post itself, but we have to give Pasternak props for not weaseling out with a "sorry if you were offended" non-apology. Instead, we dare say that he seems more aware of how words can affect body image. "Skinny does not equal healthy, and fat does not equal unhealthy," he tweeted, "and neither can determine who you are as a person." On that, we wholeheartedly agree. Here's hoping that philosophy appears in his next column — and beyond. (People.com)
Photos (Left to Right): Everett Collection/RexUSA; Everett Collection/RexUSA; Rob Latour/RexUSA.

More from Fitness

If you've ever felt like you get more out of your workout while exercising with a partner, it's not just your imagination. According to a study published ...
I know the feeling — you're planning to exercise, but you get home after a long day and it just. Feels. Impossible. Maybe you can make yourself change into...
This article was originally published on November 20, 2015. In her own words, pole dancer and fitness trainer Roz "The Diva" Mays is where she is today by...
When it comes to rock climbing, an all-or-nothing approach is key
Sometimes getting motivated to exercise can be harder than the workout itself. That’s why it helps to think of your gym time as a middle school dance: ...
The benefits of yoga are constantly touted by fitness gurus and scientific researchers alike: practicing yoga has been linked to reducing stress, boosting ...
Working out's a LOT more fun when you can do it on your own terms, in your own crib, with your own tunes, and your own friends
(Paid Content) Normally, we celebrate getting into a fitness groove. It means that we've committed — on a pretty regular basis — to laying out workout ...
Ashley Graham is breaking barriers. She's the first plus-sized model to cover the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue and she's served as our workout ...
In a move so fitting that we can’t believe we haven’t seen it already, ASOS teamed up with running shoe company Saucony to create glitter running ...
If you ask us, no workout is complete without a killer playlist — and running is no exception. Whether you prefer the trails or the treadmill, the right ...
We may not all be able to keep up a daily diet of personal training, SoulCycle, and hot yoga. But there's a lot more to learn from celebrities' workout ...
Update: This story was previously published on Nov 21, 2015. Are you sitting down? Okay, take a minute to assess: Are you slouching in your seat? Are your...
Ah, the plank. Some version of it is used in virtually every type of fitness program, from CrossFit to calisthenics to yoga to pilates, and for good reason...