Facebook & Instagram Now Allow Breastfeeding Photos, But Still No "Nudity"

rihannaemPhoto: via @badgalriri.
While Facebook has always taken a hard line against almost any kind of depiction of nudity — even a famous 19th-century painting — the social network finally decided last week to relax its policy on breastfeeding photos.
Advertisement
Like its parent company, Instagram has also loosened its restrictions on images of nursing mothers, but it still considers almost any other kind of nude photo to be in violation of its terms of service.
As Scout Willis recently learned by posting topless photos to her Instagram account in protest of its policy, the company is quick to shut down accounts that flagrantly break the rules. When Rihanna republished her nude Lui cover a couple months back, supporters of the singer posted their own nipple pics, only to have them taken down.
In its community guidelines, Instagram tries to clarify: "If you wouldn’t show the photo or video you are thinking about uploading to a child, or your boss, or your parents, you probably shouldn’t share it on Instagram."
Much like Apple's notoriously vague standards for "objectionable content" on the App Store — they previously censored everything from cartoons of two men kissing to “ex-gay” therapy apps, citing offended customers — Instagram's policy on the naked human body is somewhat open to its moderators' interpretation. "Nudity" and "mature content" are specifically not allowed on the site, but the body isn't so easily defined. Today, a topless man isn't considered naked, but a topless woman is. Go back 150 years, and a bare knee was nearly as scandalous as an exposed breast.
Advertisement
And yet breastfeeding is considered different. Somehow, a tiny human feeding from its mother transform the breast from a non-genital sexual organ — which, in fact, neuroscientists have concluded it is — with the ability to cause offense into one that does not.
You could argue, as some advocates of the #FreeTheNipple campaign have, that breastfeeding photos have special status because they aren't intended to arouse. (Not for the majority of viewers, at least.) If photos are allowed to contain nudity only if they are absent any sexual connotations, should Instagram allow photos of, say, a rectal disease, posted purely for educational purposes? What about photos from a colonoscopy or a hysteroscopy? Or is the whole interior of the genitourinary system off the table, too?
The company would counter that it is only following the same guidelines as broadcast TV networks — where sex is taboo but violence is par for the course. As Jezebel's Erin Gloria Ryan wrote in 2012, "For every accidentally exposed breast during a Super Bowl Half Time Show, there are at least 10 disgusting, decaying bodies that met unspeakable ends on CSI."
The difference is that broadcast television is a closed system in which the content is decided by the networks and the FCC. Social networks like Instagram are built by communities of users on the unfettered wilderness of the Internet, where the space between nursing mothers and triple penetration is a matter of a few hyperlinks.
A more measured policy might follow that of Twitter or Vine, which allow explicit photos and videos with the option of marking them as "sensitive content" and putting them behind screens so that users who don't want to see nudity can't, unless they click through.
Advertisement
By putting users in control, the network becomes more flexible, and arbitrary definitions of nudity, sexuality, and obscenity become more of a moot point.
Photo: via @jamie_king.
Advertisement

More from Pop Culture

As someone who is about to have a daughter, this hits me deep in my core. #NeverTrump https://t.co/BIG4J0mkM6— olivia wilde (@oliviawilde) September 24, ...
On Friday, Kylie Jenner started getting her Hidden Hills, CA, home ready for All Hallows Eve. "I’m decorating my house for Halloween," she announced via ...
At first glance, you might mistake this photo for a late '90s snapshot of Cruel Intentions-era Reese Witherspoon on the red carpet, but no. The poised ...
Jeb Bush has been a Florida governor and a presidential candidate. His latest gig? Comedian, apparently. In an opening sketch for the Emmys, Jimmy ...
NBC News reports that Pippa Middleton’s iCloud account was hacked and had her photos stolen and put up for sale. The hack came to light after U.K. paper ...
Update: Kendall Jenner has offered a response to those who did not like her ballet shoot for Vogue España, kind of. She shared several photos from the ...
Though it's barely been a month since news of cute celebrity couple du jour, Ariana Grande and Mac Miller, broke via photos of the duo locking lips at a ...
Emma Watson is most famous for her role as Hermione Granger in the internationally-known and appreciated film series, Harry Potter. She is also known for...
In an ecological niche like Hollywood, for a woman like Angelina Jolie, marriage may be more trouble than it's worth. The same goes for you. Since news ...
Kim Kardashian is objectively successful. She's covered Forbes and Paper and published a book. People pay money for piecemeal updates from her personal ...
One morning, when I was 14, I stood on a stage at my school's Black Awareness month assembly and recited the words to Maya Angelou's "Still I Rise." I ...
Yesterday, after a long fight with cystic fibrosis, Katie Prager died at the age of 26, just days after her husband, Dalton Prager, passed away from the ...
Let's play a game. Close your eyes and imagine yourself in a superhero outfit. Are you wearing a red, white, and blue bodysuit with a gold headband-cum-...
We have a mystery to solve: Katy Perry just shared a suspicious snap on Instagram. The "Rise" singer posted a photo of a pair of feet, captioned with a ...