How To Make Perfect Homemade Tomato Sauce (It's Easy!)

Photo: Courtesy of A Beautiful Mess.

By Laura Gummerman

For the past few years, there's been some tension in my marriage, and the cause, oddly enough, has been tomato sauce. Almost every time I have made spaghetti and used sauce from a jar, my husband has taken a taste and said very seriously, "We've got to do something about this sauce situation." We've looked up ways to liven up a canned sauce by adding extra ingredients, and they did help some, but he was still insistent that we find another way to solve the flavorless "sauce situation."

While we were home visiting my parents over Christmas, my foodie sister mentioned that they started making a really easy (and really delicious) homemade tomato sauce, and we told her that we were desperate to try it. She sent us the recipe after we returned home, and we made it that night with high expectations — let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

Related: 5 Ways To Enjoy Matcha Green Tea

I was a little bit skeptical because the ingredient list looked a little too simple, and the recipe sounded too easy to be good. But the secret is that it's made with a type of plumb tomato called San Marzano tomatoes, and they fill the sauce with a sweet and tangy flavor. We thought that San Marzano was a brand of tomatoes, not the type, so we were a little confused at first, but we found them pretty easily near the canned tomatoes at our local grocery store. If you can't find that particular type near you, just go with plum tomatoes, and it should still be delicious.
Photo: Courtesy of A Beautiful Mess.
Related: Tasty Tacos That Are Better Than Takeout

Recipe slightly adapted from The Mozza Cookbook's Basic Tomato Sauce

Homemade Tomato Sauce
Makes about 2 quarts

1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
1 large yellow onion, finely diced (or a Spanish onion, if you can find one)
1 tbsp kosher salt
1/2 tsp black pepper
5 cloves garlic, chopped
1/2 a medium carrot, peeled and shredded
3 tbsp fresh thyme leaves
2 28-oz cans of whole, peeled plum tomatoes (including their juices), preferably San Marzano

1. Add the oil to a large pot and heat over medium heat. Add the onion, salt, and pepper, and cook (stirring occasionally) until the onions are soft and translucent (about 7 to 10 minutes). Add the garlic and stir often for 1 minute. You don't want the garlic to brown during this step, so keep an eye on it. Add the carrot and thyme leaves, and cook for 5 to 8 minutes, stirring often, until the carrot is tender.

Photo: Courtesy of A Beautiful Mess.
Related: Easy (& Healthy!) 3-Ingredient Ice Cream

2. Add the tomatoes and their juices, bring to a boil, and reduce heat allowing the sauce to simmer for 30 minutes. You'll want to stir the sauce every few minutes so that it doesn't burn. The whole tomatoes will break down as the sauce simmers, and the sauce will thicken a bit as it cooks.

3. Season to taste with more salt and pepper once the 30 minutes is up. The recipe suggests that you run the sauce through a food mill (or you could use a blender as well) to smooth out the chunky texture, but I really like chunky sauce. Instead, I just mashed it a bit with a handheld potato masher and skipped the blending step.

The sauce can be frozen for up to six months, so you can make a giant batch and keep it around until you need more.

While we have been using this sauce simply to top pasta, it can be used in any recipe that calls for a tomato sauce (like lasagna or other Italian dishes). I can't tell you how glad we are to have discovered this recipe (thanks, Sis!), and I'm planning on adding thyme to my back porch garden this summer just so we can use it for this sauce.

Finally, there is peace and quiet in our house on spaghetti nights — though that also may be partially due to the fact that our mouths are too full of delicious sauce to talk!

Related: Spicy Food Lovers Will Be SO Into This Appetizer

More from Food & Drinks


R29 Original Series