Back in March, it was tough to anticipate what life would be like sequestered in our homes under shelter-in-place restrictions. Now, fast forward to the eight-month mark of quarantine where everything from our Zoom-relegated social interactions to our WFH-office setups feel routine. And while there’s still much uncertainty in our midst, we do know a lot more about concepts that once felt entirely foreign to us — like, for example, non-medical face masks.
Today, the CDC updated its findings surrounding these cloth face coverings, asserting that not only do they protect the people around you, but they also provide a barrier for the wearer against the continued spread of COVID-19. We not only consider masks as everyday essentials now, but we’ve also developed preferences for the options (from neck-tying to sweat-wicking and fashion-forward) that best suit our face shapes and lifestyles. But even the most informed mask shoppers can still feel overwhelmed by the dizzying selection of coverings from brands and designers that have suddenly started offering them. So, we did what we do when attempting to suss out the good from the bad: we read the reviews.
ADVERTISEMENT
Ahead, find the fruits of our painstaking internet sleuthing that details which mask styles landed most frequently in customer’s carts with positive praise. Whether you’re in the market for a pillowy soft iteration made from OEKO-TEX certified cotton, a light-catching and mood-lifting metallic model, or the mask that a pregnant woman found SO comfortable that she wore it while giving birth, there’s a top-rated option for you on this list.
COVID-19 has been declared a global pandemic. Go to the CDC website for the latest information on symptoms, prevention, and other resources.
At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. All product details reflect the price and availability at the time of publication. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.
Caraa Universal Mask
Best Pleated Mask
More than one reviewer admitted to trying different kinds of masks and finding Caraa’s masks to be the best. Customers love the stylish, sturdy-but-lightweight fabrication of the New York-based brand’s pleated face coverings.
The Hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 508 reviews on CaraaSport.com
What They’re Saying: “I LOVE these masks. They are large enough to easily cover my mouth and nose without being too tight. They are breathable, but also a stable material that does not seem likely to tear in the wash. And they are simple and stylish. I get a compliment about these masks whenever I wear them. They are my go-to face coverings now!” – Katherine C., CaraaSport.com reviewer
Outerknown Indigo Tie-Dye Mask 3-Pack
Most Eco-Friendly Mask
The “relentlessly sustainable” apparel brand Outerknown — founded by surfer Kelly Slater — makes a slew of men’s and women’s clothing that strives to be as low-impact as possible. (According to the brand’s website, 90% of fibers they source are organic, recycled, or regenerated.) Their indigo-dyed masks are no exception — made from 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton and dyed by hand with non-toxic indigo, they’re a low-impact way to keep yourself protected.
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars; 8 reviews on Outerknown.com
What They’re Saying: “Big shaka Outerknown — [these masks are] very comfortable and well fitting, all while looking good. Share the good vibes and stay safe. Mahalo.” Mark R., Outerknown.com reviewer
ADVERTISEMENT
Everlane 100% Human Windowpane Face Masks
The Most Subtly Stylish Mask
Leave it to Everlane to offer up a face covering that marries the brand’s trademark restrained style with a substantial, high-quality fabrication. Even better, 10% of the proceeds from each mask goes to the ACLU — the same goes for every product in the brand’s 100% Human collection.
The Hype: 4.51 out of 5 stars; 41 reviews on Everlane.com
What They’re Saying: “I’ve tried a few different face masks. Everlane’s are among the best. I’ve washed and worn them repeatedly. They’re breathable, comfortable and fashionable. I’d already bought one set of the grey/black/grey-black, so I decided to purchase this denim-like variety. I’ve had numerous people ask me either where I got them or if that’s THE Everlane Mask to which I reply ‘Yes.’ On top of that, they donate part of the proceeds. What more could you ask for?” — TheGraduate, Everlane.com reviewer
Future Stitch Primary Mask
Most Sweat-Wicking
A feather-light blend of Tencel and modal — along with an antimicrobial infusion of silver — make this breathable, sweat-wicking mask a top choice for those in search of all-comfort.
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars, 6 reviews on Zappos.com
What They’re Saying: “I ordered this for my husband who has had a real struggle finding a mask that is comfortable all day. He loves the fit and the sweat-wicking feature of the fabric. Plan to get him a few more.” — Mary, Zappos.com reviewer
Madewell Assorted Adjustable Face Masks (Three-Pack)
The CutestWe knew that this reader-favorite retailer would deliver on the aesthetics front — and these masks, in an assortment of chic ’n’ cheerful prints, don’t disappoint. Even better, they’re made from natural, breathable cotton.
The Hype: 4.3 out of 5 stars; 15 reviews on Madewell.com
What They’re Saying: “These are the masks you need for Covid season!! Most comfortable masks I’ve worn so far (and I’ve tried a ton). The straps are so light and easy to adjust. The masks themselves are great, breathable quality and best part is how cute the designs are!”
Rent The Runway Reusable Masks
Best All-Cotton Mask
Those with sensitive skin may find that only a breathable fabric like cotton will do — especially when it comes to an accessory that touches our faces 24-7. Rent the Runway makes a chic, all-cotton pleated mask that garnered high praise from customers.
The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 17 reviews on RentTheRunway.com
What They’re Saying: “I got my 5 pack extremely quickly. I was very impressed by the quality and the designs were neutral enough for my boyfriend and me to share a pack. I was having a lot of skin problems from other masks rubbing, particularly when running. These masks are 100% cotton and have been a huge relief to my skin. Thank you RTR for pivoting and providing this service.” – Rebecca, RentTheRunway.com reviewer
Idyllic Care Tie-Dye Face Mask
Best Tie-Dye Mask
We want all tie-dye everything in 2020 — loungewear, button-downs, socks, you name it! — and our face coverings are no exception. Reviewers describe this pretty ombre mask as soft, comfortable, and, most importantly, cute. (We couldn’t resist showcasing this reviewer’s tie-on-dye look.)
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars and 471 reviews on Etsy.com
What They’re Saying: “Super thin and breathable, and super cute and soft. This is the first cloth mask I’ve found that doesn’t gap anywhere or pull hard on my ears, and it doesn’t ride up on my nose or steam up my glasses. So happy with this purchase!” – Victoria, Etsy.com reviewer
ADVERTISEMENT
Summersalt Face Coverings
Best Workhorse Mask
If you’re going to tackle a task that requires serious endurance and focus — say, for example, giving birth (!), like the reviewer below — your mask needs to be lightweight, comfortable, and very breathable. Customer Samantha A. put Summersalt’s face covering to the ultimate test, and it passed with flying colors.
The Hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 796 reviews on Summersalt.com
What They’re Saying: “I bought these masks, as I was an expecting mom who had to wear a mask into the delivery room. I bought SEVERAL masks to make sure I had the most comfortable one I could find knowing I would be wearing it most likely while having contractions. This would definitely be the case. We got to the hospital with contractions at 3 minutes apart, and I had to wear my mask through the ER and to the delivery room. Being able to adjust the mask for comfort and the great material, I never felt like I was gasping for the breath or couldn’t breathe. If I can wear this mask at the height of labor, you can wear it to the grocery store. WEAR A MASK!” – Samantha A., Summersalt.com reviewer
Parachute Home Face Masks
Best Soft-Fabric Mask
We wouldn’t expect anything less than a pillowy soft mask from luxe-linens label Parachute. Made from the brand’s leftover Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified cotton fabric, these face coverings have reviewers praising their sublime hand-feel.
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars and 106 reviews on ParachuteHome.com
What They’re Saying: “I’ve purchased a few items from Parachute for our home and love the quality so when I saw they offered face masks I knew they would not disappoint. I missed out the first time they were offered and quickly ordered them the second time they were back in stock. Now I know face masks are nothing to be excited about but of all the face masks I’ve tried and purchased so far these are my favorite. The ties stay tied, the mask fits well, it’s super soft, and now that I’ve laundered them, they hold up well too! I would definitely purchase again but with 5 masks, (actually, 4 as I reluctantly parted with one to my husband) I should be good. I’m looking forward to the day when I can walk into a store sporting bright red lipstick but until then I’ll be wearing one of these!” – Laura F., ParachuteHome.com reviewer
Heroine Sport Metallic Face Mask
Best Fashion Mask
COVID-19 got you down? Yeah, us too. For anyone who believes in the healing power of fashion, however, Heroine Sport’s shimmering masks may offer some solace. You may not be hitting the club anytime soon, but you can channel your festive energy with these face coverings.
The Hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 16 reviews on SaksFifthAvenue.com
What They’re Saying: “It’s so upsetting to have to wear masks everywhere we go now but when I put these on and they match all of my outfits, it makes coping with the situation a lot easier. The mask is very comfortable and it’s also stylish and fits my face perfectly. You can even add a filter to it if you want. I get so many compliments on them. If they made them in more colors, I would buy those too.” – Cindy S., SaksFifthAvenue.com reviewer
Brave New Look Protective Face Mask
Best Breathable Mask
The sporty and the sweaty among us are always on the hunt for the most feather-weight mask that money can buy — and this top-rated cotton-spandex face covering may offer the best combination of flexible comfort and breathability.
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars and 1,053 reviews on BraveNewLook.com
What They’re Saying: “We looked long and hard for a mask that was breathable to get through our steamy summer. These are great — breathes nicely, fit well, look good. Going to get more for the rest of the family!” — Lauren, BraveNewLook.com reviewer
Reebok Face Covers
Best Workout Mask
Need to sweat-wick in eco-friendly style? Not only are Reebok’s masks workout-friendly, but they’re also made from 93% recycled polyester.
The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 1.535 reviews on Reebok.com
What They Are Saying: “THE ONLY MASK I CAN USE WHEN WORKING OUT.
Lightweight and breathable. I gave my karate instructor one and she said it was the most breathable mask has had used so far.” – COJ9, Reebok.com reviewer
ADVERTISEMENT
Hammacher Schlemmer Antibacterial Cooling Face Mask
Best Antibacterial Mask
Hammacher Schlemmer’s high-tech mask is so advanced it practically has its own weather system. With a cooling nylon/polyester blend fabrication and — wait for it — antibacterial silver nanoparticles, this mask is straight out of a science fiction novel. But a fairytale it isn’t: reviewer found the mask to be as cool and funk-free as promised.
The Hype: 4 out of 5 stars and 432 reviews on HammacherSchlemmer.com
What They’re Saying: “I got this mask for the cooling fabric and also the ability to use a filter (included). I needed to be able to wear it in the heat of GA and FL and also use it on flights. I've now had it for a month. Have worn on multiple flights and it's comfortable and I feel safe. I got them for both my daughters — one in FL and one in TX. I use it both without the filter when I'm outside in the heat and also with the filter when I spend extended time inside. I'm super happy with this purchase and recommend if you are in a warm climate. And, of course, you can breathe fully through it — with or without the filter your breathing is not impeded.” – Jen, HammacherSchlemmer.com reviewer
Athleta Everyday Non-Medical Masks
Best Family Pack Mask
With an array of muted, gender-neutral tones and an adjustable fit, Athleta’s five-pack of breathable masks is fun for the whole family. Numerous reviewers cited clan-wide approval of the affordable face coverings.
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 4,005 reviews on Athleta.com
What They’re Saying: “Just perfect!
Oh, my word. These are the best masks out there! They somehow fit me (5’4”), my husband (6’2”), and my 9-year-old son!!! They’re almost silky fabrics, have a wire inside to conform to your nose, soft elastic, great adjusting devices on both ears so the elastic fits various face sizes, and great colors that go with everything. A win everywhere!” – LMCD, Athleta.com reviewer
Nordstrom Adult Face Masks In Assorted Colors
Best Adjustable Mask
Customers who have to mask up for long hours appreciate the adjustable, convertible ear straps on Nordstrom’s simple, affordable face coverings.
The Hype: 4.3 out of 5 stars and 177 reviews on Nordstrom.com
What They’re Saying: “I love this mask. You have the options to tie it around your head over your ear (which is better) or ear loop it. As a front liner I developed redness at the back of my ear wearing masks all the time. At least before I go to work my ears are not sore due to looping the face masks. Thank you so much. Can you please make more designs???” – jhetski, Nordstrom.com reviewer
Daniela Tabois Bridal Scallop Lace Face Mask
Best Bridal Face Mask
We know that the pandemic hasn’t stopped people from getting hitched — its simply changed everything about the way we get married, including what we wear. If you must wear a mask while celebrating a marriage, Etsy seller Daniela Tabois makes sumptuous, event-friendly face coverings with festive trims like lace and sequins.
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars; 233 reviews on Etsy
What They’re Saying: “This mask made my day! And it will be the best part of my outfit for a small wedding I’ll be attending. It fits perfectly. Excellent quality. Daniela is very responsive and the item shipped in less than 24 hours!” — Lauren Solomon, Etsy.com reviewer
Hope Love Shine Stylish Cotton Face Masks
Best Assorted Mask
Roll the dice with this five-pack of top-rated masks — customers will receive a surprise assortment of four sweet prints and solid color. We could see these being a fun party favor option for your micro-wedding or hyper-intimate birthday dinner.
The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 1,648 reviews on Amazon
What They’re Saying: “I am very happy with the colors I received. They are well-made masks, with good solid stitching. My biggest like is that they have pockets for filters. These masks wash and wear well so they get a big 👍 in every area from me. Also I appreciate the customer service from this company as I reached out to them and they responded quickly. My masks got here in a short amount of time, so I'm a very happy customer!” – Rose, Amazon reviewer
ADVERTISEMENT
Gildan Reusable 3-Layer Cotton Face Mask
Best Basic Mask
From the makers of heavy-duty, sporty cotton separates comes the most pared-down mask on the market, with an interior cotton layer that will keep skin happy. If you’re a fan of the LBD or the plain black tee, this mask is for you. The 24-pack also offers serious bang for your buck, so they’re a great buy for a larger group.
The Hype: 4.3 out of 5 stars and 3,806 reviews on Amazon
What They’re Saying: “Well made and comfortable/secure for occupational wear. The price is unbelievable for these well-made masks. They are professional-grade durable material on the outside but soft cotton inside. These not only fulfill masking requirements but being triple-layer and tightly woven fabric I feel they are very effective.” – value_quest, Amazon.com reviewer
Aerie Reusable Denim Face Mask (Set of Three)
Best Small-Face Mask
For our smaller-visaged sisters who feel overwhelmed by the standard proportions of an off-the-rack mask, Aerie’s iteration offers a smaller footprint and lighter-weight fabrication.
The Hype: 4.2 out of 4 stars and 21 reviews on AE.com
What They Are Saying: “I’ve been looking for a face mask that does not fog up my glasses and is lighter feeling. I found it with these! The bendable wire on the nose bridge part of the mask bends exactly where it should to keep my glasses from fogging up. The mask is smaller fitting than others I have bought (which cover practically your whole face), so this works great for me being that I’m claustrophobic. Great job American Eagle!! I'm going to purchase more in other colors!” – Elizabeth, AE.com reviewer
ADVERTISEMENT
Load more...
ADVERTISEMENT
