Just when we thought we were over a show revolving around the lives of high school students,
Riverdale sucked us back in again . But aside from the small-town drama and seemingly never-ending suspense, what really keeps us clicking yes to "Are You Still Watching?" are the standout beauty looks. From K.J. Apa's faux red hair to Camila Mendes' award-winning brows, we can't get enough.
Which is why, when Lili Reinhart (
a.k.a. Betty Cooper) shares her makeup and skin regimens with the rest of us, we take notes. She's recorded her entire skin-care routine on Instagram, and gave the world a behind-the-scenes look at her everyday makeup via . She's spread the wisdom of her application secrets, and the exact products she uses to keep her face looking natural and glowy.
Ahead, click through Reinhart's virtual makeup bag and medicine cabinet to see her entire beauty routine. And — unlike the pricier routines of
Kim Kardashian West or Bella Hadid — it's one we can definitely relate to.
In a recent interview with
, Reinhart gave us an IRL look at how she gets her
. "I used to pluck all these hairs right here," she
, referencing the inner corner of her brows. "Which I learned was a big mistake. You should not do that." For shape and dimension, Reinhart uses the trusty
Anastasia Beverly Hills's Brow Powder palette
and a small angled brush to enhance her natural arches.
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Brow Pro Palette,
that she's loving peachy pink shadow for a pop of color on her eyes at the moment. She uses a blush tone from the
Stila Eyes Are the Window palette
to brighten her lids, then brushes the dark brown shade along her upper lash line for definition. "I feel like if I don't run a little bit of shadow or liner on my lash line, my eyes sort of disappear," Reinhart
in the video.
Eyes Are The Window Shadow Palette,
that her go-to her-lips-but-better lip color is
MAC Satin Lipstick
in the shimmery light pink shade Brave.
This cult classic clay mask seems to be stocked in every beauty guru's cabinet. According to Reinhart, it was
model Madeline Hill
who recommended the cheap find for acne-prone skin.
Indian Healing Clay, $7.89, available at
editors swear by this mask for
clearing up cystic acne
, and Reinhart uses it three times a week when her skin is clear and every day when there's a breakout.
Rapid Response Detox Masque, $60.50, available at
This at-home exfoliating peel leaves your skin so radiant, you might think you just left a facial. Reinhart uses this antioxidant-rich formula once a week.
Triple Berry Smoothing Peel, $86.50, available at
This two-step serum and sleeping mask fights dullness, which is ideal for an actress with long shoot days.
DreamDuo Overnight Transforming Treatment, $59, available at
Reinhart has tons of breakout-busting recommendations, including this sulfur-infused treatment that beauty editors also swear by.
Drying Lotion, $17, available at
Reinhart mixed her own scrub made with papaya and pistachio at the St. Ives
pop-up mixing bar in New York
. But this existing favorite includes a similar hydrating blend of avocado and vitamin E.
Daily Hydrating Vitamin E and Avocado Body Lotion, $4.99, available at
When non-stop flights start taking a toll on Reinhart's lips, she reaches for this lip mask to keep hers smooth.
Lip Sleeping Mask, $20, available at
To keep her skin in check, Reinhart also swears by overnight masks, like this one, to do all the work while she catches her beauty sleep.
Water Sleeping Mask, $25, available at
Sorry, Betty Cooper stans — Reinhart isn't a natural blonde. But, if you aren't either, she recommends this weekly treatment for damaged ends.
K-PAK Color Therapy Luster Lock, $19.99, available at
Or try this hydrating hair mask, which leaves hair smooth and soft.
Ultimate Remedy Extreme Restoration Treatment, $68, available at
This hair oil created by
Hailey Baldwin's colorist Ryan Pearl
, and loved by the
star. Warm a dime-sized amount in the palm of your hands before smoothing through ends after your weekly shampoo.
Hair Oil Color Protectant Oil, $28, available at