"Which celebrity have you been on dates with that we don't know about?," Kemp asked Puth.
Instead of evading the question, the 25-year-old singer got candid with Kemp.
"Lea Michele. Done," proclaimed Puth.
Refinery29 has reached out to representatives for both Puth and Michele, and will update this post should we hear back.
If Puth and Michele did go on a few dates, they likely kept things pretty low-key. However, it does make one wonder if any of Puth's songs are secretly about the Scream Queens star.
Though the "We Don't Talk Anymore" singer has kept this alleged romance under wraps, he has been outspoken about previous relationships — or, rather, his non relationships. During a guest appearance on The Elvis Duran Show in April of 2016, he stated that, despite popular tabloid rumors, he has never dated Meghan Trainor or Selena Gomez.
If these two really did date, as Puth suggested to Kemp, then hopefully they parted ways amicably. If romance isn't in the cards anymore with these two, perhaps a duet is still possible?