Mystery Cologne E

Christene: "This one smells warm and cozy. It has some woodsy tones to it, and maybe some vanilla and melon. It smells like a man who puts a lot of thought into his scent selection. It doesn't smell synthetic to me — it smells really natural, like it could be an essential-oil blend or something. I'd say this one is my favorite."

Kristian: "Oh, it’s very sweet. It reminds me of high school. It's flowery with some citrus. I think it's downmarket. What kind of guy do I see wearing this? A trying-too-hard type of person."

Connie: "This one smells like what an older, geriatric woman would wear. It's kind of spicy and kind of floral-y as well. It smells like the sitting room of an old ladies' salon. The kind of guy who would wear this would have gelled hair, an Italian suit, and probably plucked eyebrows."

Annie: "This smells like something one of my guy friends would wear and I’d be like, 'Ugh, you’re a creep.' But, it’s fine, if a little fruity. These scents are all too fancy-boy for me. I would say it’s good date cologne for a girl who likes cologne."

Gabriel: "Musky, a little bit of licorice and liquor. This is for the guy who wants to get some. It would go with leather boots and dark clothes. It does have some more perfume-y, lilac notes at the end, but I think that's actually good on a date."