Awards and titles in Tinseltown are as commonplace as Loubies on a red carpet, and this most recent Men's Health countdown of the sexiest women of all time, reminds us of how trivial they can be. Honoring Jennifer Aniston as the number one hottie of history—and don't get us wrong, we love, love, love Rachel— just seems like a stretch. And while seeing pics of the bikini-clad 42-year-old (or, hello those Smartwater commercials! That hair!) always make us seethe with jealousy, we've got to ask, has Justin Theroux really snagged every past and present man's fantasy? Weigh in on this hot topic below.