Lexi Nisita, associate community editor

To give: "A certain someone is always complaining that he can't find a nice jacket at his usual spot, a.k.a. the Goodwill. I've got no problem with secondhand, but I know this jacket would be a hit. He might not have the guts to splurge, but I do!"
J. Crew Worker Jacket, $168, available at J. Crew.

To get: "I've been eyeing this Daniel Wellington watch for a while. It's got a definite menswear vibe, so maybe we could share it? Two for the price of one! I know it's on the expensive side, so for the record, I'd be equally pleased with a $20 vintage version."
Daniel Wellington Classic St. Andrews Watch, $235, available at Need Supply.