Want all this in your inbox?
Get the Refinery29 Newsletter
You're in for a treat...
Thanks for signing up!
Please upgrade your browser for the best Refinery29 experience. Read more.
Research by Meirav Devash
First discovered by Queen Bey after seeing their YouTube covers of her "Pretty Hurts," sisters Chloe and Halle Bailey comprise one of the hippest singing sister acts around. They are also some of the sweetest people you will ever meet, forgoing handshakes for heartfelt hugs and exuding gratitude for every opportunity that has come their way.
The two have a lot to be thankful for: "Drop," the first single off their new album, Sugar Symphony, features some of the most breathtaking imagery to go along with their heavenly voices and is causing major buzz in the music world. The duo just ended their stint on Beyoncé's "Formation" tour and will be hitting the road for their concert tour next month.
When asked to be judges for our awards, 18-year-old Chloe and 16-year-old Halle jumped at the chance. "We just do what we like, dibble and dabble — we're not pros or anything," says Halle. "We're the voice for the kids who just do what they like and don't know too much about it. We're the people walking into it not knowing anything and doing what speaks to them."
Their now-signature locs immediately drew our attention, so of course we had to ask all about them. "I love my hair. I love that I stand out, and whatever hairstyle you wear is all about how you rock it and your confidence," notes Chloe. As to caring for them, they're fans of SheaMoisture, Carol's Daughter, and "lots of coconut oil."
While sifting through the MASSIVE pile of products we sent their way, the girls had some clear favorites. We had a hard time getting Chloe to wipe off the OCC Artifact Lip Tar, while Halle kept reaching for the Drunk Elephant B Hydra Intensive Gel Moisturizer. For so-called beauty novices, these talented ladies sure seemed hip to the coolest product picks.
With her signature style of soft, effortless waves, it's no wonder stars like Lauren Conrad and Lucy Hale flock to hairstylist Kristin Ess. The fiery-maned Ess is also a cofounder — with Conrad — of the popular The Beauty Department site, where she teaches readers cool new ways to use hair accessories and what the hell drying gloves are.
While honored to be a part of the judging process, Ess got real and said what we were all thinking: The products that landed on her doorstep were the best part of this whole enchilada.
"I love communicating with people digitally and online, but as a girl, two massive boxes arriving at your door is like Christmas," she says. "Aside from that is getting to see the new things, the innovations in our industry, because there are so many brands out there trying to do their thing and I think it's really cool."
She adds, "It's one thing to be asked to be a judge on a small, digital online-voting thing, but this is the new beauty awards. If I [click] into a story and Refinery has their stamp of approval on it, I'm buying it." We're blushing.
As a hairstylist, Ess went in knowing a lot about the featured hair-care brands — she counts Oribe Hair Care as one of her go-tos. Makeup, on the other hand, was new for her. "I feel like hairdressers never get makeup dibs or introductions to new products. You see things and try to take notes [on set], but you also have to do your job. Give me all of the makeup."
Ironically, among all that makeup, there was only one product that truly stole her heart. "Oh my god, the Too Faced matte liquid lipstick. I feel like I can throw out my old ones, and that will be my one."
YouTube star and L.A.-based makeup artist Claire Marshall is no stranger to testing beauty products for her roughly 870,000 YouTube fans. "Anything that comes to my inbox, I'm going to treat the same way for what my needs are versus what someone else's needs are. I tried to look at these products from the perspective of someone who's using it," she says.
Unlike our other judges, who dove headfirst into their boxes o' products with unbridled glee, Marshall was all business with her process.
"I laid out all of the categories across my office floor and paired up the product with category in order to have the description of each product," she explains. "I took a category at a time and just went through it. Some of them were fairly easy — if I was already familiar with the brand, or a specific product, it was a lot easier to make a decision."
As for how her influencer background applied to her judging, Marshall says it was just an extension of her usual process. "A lot of beauty influencers are trying out products and they're telling people in every video what they're currently liking. It was just on a grander scale. I'm giving my real opinion of the products as a real person."
Marshall was another fan of the Drunk Elephant moisturizer: "It was a brand I've never tried before, and now it sits on my vanity and I use it every morning." The Giorgio Armani Maestro UV Defense Primer Serum is also a new player in her beauty routine.
Speaking of routines, you won't find Marshall telling her followers there's a certain aesthetic they should be striving for. "There's no rules when it comes to beauty," she notes. "It's all about expression, and people are becoming less and less scared about that." Hear, hear.
For anyone who complains about the younger generation being unmotivated and self-involved: You've clearly never heard of Mars. The 16-year-old Gen-Z self-described creative is the cofounder (along with 25-year-old artist Jam) of the Art Hoe movement — a way for POC to both create and consume content that changes the conversation around depictions of race and sexuality.
Identifying as gender-queer, Mars notes that their contribution to the judging panel was to show that makeup goes beyond sex and gender. "Beauty shouldn't be a tool only designed for conventionally attractive people, and shouldn't be marketed towards only cis-passing people."
They continue, "This experience definitely opened me up to that, and I really hope people will learn that makeup isn't an exclusive thing."
That attitude, they say, is ever-so-slowly changing. Speaking with their friends recently, Mars noted that it's great to see more POC wearing boldly colored makeup or pastel braids.
"A lot of Black girls tend to shy away from those colors with the fear of being stereotyped as 'ratchet' or 'ghetto,'" they say. "So if we market beauty in a way that it's available for everyone to explore without the fear of being profiled, beauty would be so much better."
As an admitted face-mask addict, Mars dove right into testing that category first. Their favorite? "The Kiehl's Turmeric & Cranberry Seed Energizing Radiance Masque that decreases the redness, but [gives] a very dewy, fresh-faced glow."
And while the majority of the hair products weren't a match for their textured hair, they were impressed with the Madam C.J. Walker Beauty Culture Jamaican Black Castor & Murumuru Oils Edge Control & Shape Paste (whew, that's a mouthful). "I don't normally use gels for my hair or my edges because I find it leaves my hair very brittle and harsh. But I liked that this contained castor oil left my hair moisturized, while also slimming it down in the front."
While they loved testing out all of the products, they believe that there is more to this story than just appreciating pretty things. "We can use beauty to build a dialogue [around race] because I feel like people shy away from that conversation and political dialogue out of fear. The fact that beauty is [now] being marketed as this inclusive and multifaceted thing is super-important, since it's going across all these attainable channels [like YouTube and Instagram] for everyone to get the message." We hear you loud and clear.
As the founder of R29's beauty department, features director Megan McIntyre has seen pretty much everything (blackhead vacuum, anyone?). The self-described beauty nerd has a tendency to hoard everything from brightening serums to purple lipsticks — for the record, her current favorite is MAC's Liptensity Lipstick in Hellebore.
Because of that, she was one of the tougher judges, not easily swayed by pretty packaging. Innovation was top of mind, as well as tech savviness, new ingredients, and sometimes the just plain weirdness of the nominees.
"One of the best things about beauty is there is always something new and exciting just around the corner," she says. "It's the reason I love my job so much. That and all the free mascara, obviously."
Speaking of mascara, McIntyre was majorly impressed by Pacifica's Dream Big Volumizing Mascara and its nifty shape-shifting wand. She also gave top marks to Julep's Love Your Bare Face Hydrating Cleansing Oil for its ability to wipe away every last trace of foundation and make skin feel soft and smooth post-cleansing.
In addition to beauty newness, McIntyre says that the cultural shift she's seen in the last decade or so of her work as a beauty editor is its own type of innovation. "Seeing brands not only market to POC, but also start to realize that showing a white model alongside a Black model or Asian model doesn't really give you credibility as being woke anymore. Not that it ever really did."
Which is why the advent of brands starting to more holistically represent those of color, as well as use gender-free and plus-size marketing, is encouraging. "From CoverGirl appointing James Charles as a spokesmodel and the boys-in-beauty movement on YouTube, there's been a real effort to expand our definition of that word. We've got a ways to go, but it's important that we're — for the most part — aware of it and working towards a change."