Lipliner
"I can dig it as a base layer, or a matte, subtle color worn like regular lipstick, but there is nothing — NOTHING — that bothers me more than lipliner taken literally. That '90s, Pam-Anderson outline around the mouth, filled in with metallic lipstick, is just the worst."
— Lexi Nisita, associate community editor

Too Faced Perfect Lips in Neutral Pink, $17, available at Too Faced.

Photographed by Chantal Adair