Flaunt a new beauty product in front of us and we're like a deranged kid hyped up on sugar in a toy store: WE WANT IT ALL. It's no surprise our apartments read like an episode of Hoarders: Envision vanity tables, bookshelves, and desks littered with half-used hair potions and cover-uppers.
But, while our wallets may be tempted by shiny new things, we always come back to the one or two superstars that get used 'til the bitter end. And, that's when things get really desperate. For the shadows we've hit pan on, the tinted moisturizers we've cut open for every last, glowy drop, and the brow pencils we've been in committed relationships with longer than with, well, our S.O.s — read on.