If You Can Ignore The Glitter Overkill, You Might Just Enjoy Gatsby

UPDATE: The glitz and glamour and Carey/Tobey/Leo group shots that came with all those Gatsby premieres are behind us now, but there's fresh excitement ahead. The title is finally hitting DVD/VOD/iTunes, etc. next week, on Tuesday, August 27. To celebrate, we're giving one of you guys a Blu-ray combo pack (including a normal DVD, in case you happen to be Blu-ray-less) for free. Just take to the comments with a vote for your favorite Fitzgerald story or novel, add in some proof of its superiority, and we'll announce a winner on Monday, August 28.
daisy-buchanan-jay-gatsbyPhoto: Courtesy of Warner Brothers.
Advertisement
Originally published on May 6, 2013:
Some of us really love Baz Luhrmann. We might own Moulin Rouge and have dreams of dying glamorously young (of consumption, of course) as a result. We might also contend that Romeo + Juliet is a pretty compelling reading of Shakespeare's most overexposed play (The dolls in her bedroom? Genius.). Oh, and that Chanel ad he made? Magical. However, none of that meant that we had particularly high hopes for the Australian director's retelling of F. Scott Fitzgerald's most famous work. Mostly because Luhrmann is all about glitz and glamour and in-your-face explosive moments, and Gatsby's about the slow burn — the unspoken regrets and the quiet passion.
And yet, we thoroughly enjoyed it. We're still a little perplexed about why it was shot in 3-D, but let's overlook that. And, we're also willing to overlook the overly stylistic moments that are Luhrmann's calling card. Because we feel like he understands the character study that is The Great Gatsby, and he mostly does it justice — without ever getting bogged down by an overly romanticized idea of what is essentially one of the worst love stories, ever.
Fitzgerald, in his dysfunctional marriage (see: Tender Is The Night and The Beautiful and Damned), with his outsider-looking-in obsessions (Tobey Maguire is the most wonderful stand-in for the writer, in his role as Nick Carraway, by the way), wasn't trying to create some beautiful snapshot of an inspirational love affair. In his novel, he might write that "it was all for her," but Daisy ultimately exists to inform our understanding of the rags-to-riches story that is Jay Gatsby. And don't worry; we're not here to complain about her lack of agency or her inability to make a decision or a commitment. She isn't a disappointment because she's a woman; she's a disappointment because she's a piece of a careless, reckless couple representative of a careless, reckless society. And Baz Luhrmann shows us all of that. Beautifully. He's never distracted by the romance, although the tender moments of awkward reunion feel believable in a slightly more unorthodox fashion than we might have expected. No, he sets the shallow mirage of devotion to Lana Del Rey (An intentional wink? Probably not, but we had to ask.), singing, "Will you still love me, when I'm no longer young and beautiful." And the answer is no. We all know that, and fortunately, so does our director.
gatsby-carey-mulliganPhoto: Courtesy of Warner Brothers.
Are there moments where Luhrmann beats us over the head with symbolism? Obviously. Are there strains of ideas that he picks up and can't quite follow through on? Absolutely. Particularly his treatment of race and discrimination. He pokes at the idea, with a little help from Tom and Daisy, but he can't quite complete his thought, and ultimately, he abandons it altogether, in favor of keeping focus on the title character.
Advertisement
But he does that pretty well. He toys with the timeline in which we receive information, but it all works. Relying heavily on a narrator (Maguire as Carraway, employing the same typewriter trick as Christian in Moulin Rouge, particularly for those powerful closing lines), he shows us not just the glossy parts and the ugly parts of the glorified gangster, but also the conflicted parts — the ones the character can't understand, and the shortcomings that ultimately lead to his demise — in a pretty even-handed way. So, what we're saying is this: Do we want to see Luhrmann adapt our favorite Fitzgerald work, This Side of Paradise? Not really. But did the movie make us revisit some of our ideas about a short-lived Golden Age and its obvious parallels to the present day, as well as our understanding of Gatsby himself? A little bit. So...success!

More from Entertainment

Two episodes into the third season of How To Get Away With Murder, we're one step closer to finding out who dies in the fire at Annalise's (Viola Davis) ...
The Final Five are national treasures. They're basically a collection of perfect, perfectly happy humans. And who wouldn't be, especially after turning in ...
We've written extensively about how all the American Horror Story seasons are linked. But we didn't realize that Roanoke would be the Rosetta Stone through...
It’s pretty obvious that movie and television characters don’t look the way most of us do, and that it's a problem. But rarely do we actually talk about ...
Lip Sync Battle just released a clip to promote its next season, and it features a pretty impressive performance. A large cast of celebrities including ...
There's a rumor going around on Twitter that Hilary Duff and Justin Bieber are making music together. It appears to have started with the Hilary Duff News...
Lady Gaga just confirmed what we knew to be true: She will be the headliner at the Super Bowl halftime show. Gaga announced her official involvement with ...
(Paid Content) When a movie like Disney's Queen of Katwe comes out, you know award season is upon us. The inspiring new film has all the makings of an ...
Real feminist Portland bookstore In Other Words has had enough of the fake feminist Portland bookstore portrayed on Portlandia. The sketch in question ...
HBO has a big problem on its hands. Its flagship show, the most-watched in the channel's history, is ending. So however Game of Thrones comes to its ...
In a cover interview with Elle, Miley Cyrus threw some major shade at Mariah Carey. "I’ve never really been a fan, because it’s so much about Mariah ...
Rumor had it that while Carrie and Samantha were friends on-screen, Sarah Jessica Parker and Kim Cattrall were enemies behind the scenes. But Parker ...
Selena Gomez just dropped a new song that has her asking if you can keep a secret. It seems like she's the one who's keeping secrets, though. Gomez ...
Olivia Pope has joined Angelina Jolie's legal team — sort of. According to People, Jolie has hired Judy Smith, the real woman that Pope's character was...