Back Off, Santa: These Cookies Are All Ours

cookieintro
There’s a lot to love this time of year — parties, presents, Bing Crosby. However, there’s one thing we look forward to more than anything: COOKIES. True, these sweets aren’t exactly rare year-round, but there is something special about seasonal goodies. Gingerbread just isn’t gingerbread in July, after all.
Advertisement
So, we sorted through our personal favorites, family recipes, and the good, old classics, and came up with four must-have (must-bake, must-share, must-cancel-dinner-plans-to-stay-home-and-make) Christmas cookie recipes to share with you. Nothing too complicated, but all sure to find you fighting over who gets to lick the spoon (go for the eyes, the dough is so worth it). Check out our step-by-step guide to baking bliss and have yourself a merry little confection. We’re having seven. For breakfast.
Raspberry-Almond Thumbprints
Almost as seasonal as a cinnamon stick, the scent of sweet almond is one of the best things your kitchen can make. Then there’s the taste. No offense to almonds, but almond paste is hard to beat (and hard to stop eating once the package is open). This cookie is an all-around hit because of its nutty, not-too-sweet base, combined with a tart and fruity center.
7ojxgsvtonffwj4jto3q3nabecctwdayg7a88xhbcny
Ingredients:
2 ½ cups flour
¾ cup sugar
½ cup almond paste
½ tsp baking powder
2 sticks unsalted butter
1 egg yolk
2 tsp almond extract
½ raspberry preserves
Preheat oven to 350. Combine flour, sugar, and baking powder.
Advertisement
fyio-rifwti-fqd69akrsezkjydjwt5l9cnxlqyevw
Using your fingers, crumble almond paste into the flour mixture.
9xbd9agxfwl1qn1lktr-f3yfhk78ko7zlxcvcidov6y
Melt butter and pour into dough. This will help the almond paste break apart more.
dilqu1ruhtvwwy6jbdxnnf-yncmqeedyw9pyfmfpxas
Whisk until well combined.
h4hlzflh71enpzgwq4s1j2eunjexzddf9tncn9t8ihs-1
Add extract and egg yolk, and mix in.
rvqfgcljytgo7ob6yt80dulk9mcxlinnxvrvktvp844
mibvx7cddmxi-tu4iaoqozkckzecnu1xy0zcazmcjea
544pzl2rlmdwvvnjh-airyz9dzz-tptposs4mee2upq
Use your hands to form the dough into one piece.
Advertisement
xf6-wu929rdxa66g1jsanq5mxq9nh-1riqutxzxszoi
Pull off large chunks of dough and form into balls (a little bigger than a golf ball), and lay onto a lined or greased baking sheet.
kpfoz2mmrq5hku7gojzjpslhccgrd5hyhs-zecgc5k8
Using a teaspoon, press indentations into the center of each ball. Note: The edges will crack, but if they crack too much, bake the cookies for 10 minutes, then press the indentations in.
79k6hquqi5xwqdtvdakyvkkwg3e-zjdici1plhaysa8
Decant preserves into a small plastic bag, and snip one corner off.
03y66udjossnhqrzhcnwvsxcbjtgfwtpvfzj5xbhjyg
klyy-iefqgzmwuwsveskgfi4wwahra9mqlus053of4
Squeeze jam into the middle of each cookie.
tpfwpllm9-fu2squfyskxwdsdqhe11jwyx-qtuznula
Bake for 10-15 minutes (less if you prebaked), removing when the bottom edges are slightly browned. These won’t get much darker.
Advertisement
But they will get delicious-er.
ZZDr_HZQr5agwji3Kzbos-ebO4-4JTfId1-bdxQ15IU
Almond Meringues
Meringues might seem complicated, but they're actually very easy — all you need is time and an electric mixer. The chopped almonds in the middle add a different type of crunch to the crisp egg whites, and anyone who tries them will be surprised by this unusual textural addition! Plus, cool the cookies in the refrigerator and hold one close to your ear to hear them crackling away (it's the winter version of the seashell trick!).
ArZvvxRRiAVfWdCjeS936jMSphXWBuuF4uysTGIX1zg
Ingredients:
3 large egg whites
1 tsp baking soda
3/4 cup sugar (many recipes suggest caster sugar; we got by just fine with granulated)
1/2 teaspoon almond extract
1/3 cup chopped almonds
Parchment paper
Advertisement
Preheat oven to 200 degrees. These cookies take a while to cook, so be sure you have at least three hours at home to supervise the baking.
Chop up almonds into small pieces and set aside.
oyPKaoCpgFgiuJ9z9d3wMGAsc_aPqzn0hYyxksFA-KI
Separate egg whites and combine with sugar and baking soda.
XloxfeCS3OgMfMZQ6rjGsYD7kvG41sTs3b5ZB8Eev2Q
Beat mixture using an electric mixer until it just holds soft peaks.
HQb7Ok7x9P6hqkBFJNuEfFStytybafs-yHTaO8Idmh8
smYfYIC2PWKxl4xSEvugap_92CXxBTCGJWM0aqseVxY
Add almond extract.
Advertisement
xhE-v0N7Y3iKTt205X-NKVVrOUyeXhwx04SJD5JT6mE
Transfer some of the mixture into a bag and snip off the corner.
Fl4N9jTHoYuwhnojkLGYMIBHlcP-KDk2eTCF0Hj5F_A
Gently squeeze a first layer of meringue onto the parchment paper, applying light downward pressure to keep the cookie relatively flat.
o32vJiJs1Q24xdjaU8wIb5Y3IknLqG7l5YJdf9tcx9g
Sprinkle chopped almonds over the first layer.
txY1SG0QTyfJ112Ry59SRLfzZZFxmFkXH4lVBYcl_Rk
Add a second layer of meringue over the almonds. This time, if you want a taller, more sculptured final product, you can allow it to pile up by not applying downward pressure as you squeeze.
tF-IIAnbdsdoahYn3eIeXUUacu970F0iaOf32b7cnYg
Bake meringues for at least 1 1/2 hours. Feel them periodically — once they can be removed from the parchment paper with ease, they are done. If you're uncertain, remove one, allow it to cool and harden, and try it. A little gooey spot in the middle never hurt anyone; in fact, it's delicious!
Advertisement
lEBba-labRskQF2E1ByThPHfaspJI5E4u_Y7YaR8b0M
Nail polish: Through The Fire by Deborah Lippmann.
Chocolate-Peppermint Sugar Cookies
If there’s one thing we love in this world, it’s classic sugar cookies. One thing we hate? Waiting for them. Traditional recipes dictate that you wait four (a.k.a. a zillion) hours for the dough to chill in the fridge. Not this one. We took it a step further by dipping them in chocolate and adding a little candy-cane crunch. Perhaps it’s a sin to mess with a classic, but we didn’t think you’d mind.
bJYYmuL1NacxArBKXWk4klXkSqxLg99eXMp6RKtsjgM
Ingredients:
2 ¾ cups flour
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp baking powder
2 sticks unsalted butter, melted or softened
1 ½ cups sugar
1 egg
1 tbsp vanilla extract
1 cup chocolate chips of your choice
½ cup crushed candy canes
Advertisement
Preheat oven to 375. Combine all dry ingredients and whisk well.
pqlDeRqS4SOH7vYv7h7Kn1uMpyWV2Os5ndqc8dBkzlY
Add butter...
FVZhi1jJnlf6_7O7A7nr8r6eGvWCXcFsEH1eJAv2EKQ
….egg...
ShE8umcfosEQwCwkgifCrWLBru_dfWYbIdBKzoA2Wx0
…and vanilla.
G3RIk-hnTBz5v3ZnoCQeg3MVz6svJ3EXn-oPtJyH0II
Stir well, and if necessary, use your hands to form a large dough ball.
Advertisement
dhupbRUgNlYm6zF0CaTwQuQ2tkaZoXncZpIFmnduGZU
Form cookies into balls, and line up on a baking sheet.
29kEnfDjYB5FJBxVPCxaaHWhQm4qI2ia5uhn-Rji2GA
Bake for eight-10 minutes, until the surface just begins to brown and the top cracks a bit.
GobhLl9tqzu2km058Rod-B4S4HvnIObeIJaRaTL3erw
Remove from the oven and let the cookies cool entirely.
Using the back of a wooden spoon (a soup can works great, too!), crush candy canes in a small plastic bag, and pour minty bits onto a small plate.
Huw2vzQaK-OFcjdIdquewMjncaFhNeo2hjfRz8OT-Bc
Melt chocolate and, tilting at an angle to create depth, dip in a cookie half way.
Advertisement
R6Tnso5-YBKBNbysi2yLpTmVlKy_B71zoabJ--OmuGA
Let excess chocolate drip off, and quickly press into the candy cane bits. Lay face up on a plate to cool completely.
J7cP9hi4DIUrwa9IFqTAavuzn5EO_Aj6OKZOgW-G4gI
Commence to NOM.
7F0mfXE3lK7D9cp57rHyD9462q-D44icfVgRK4sW5nE
Pfeffernusse
We got this recipe from one of our editor's mother, who says she may or may not have pulled it from Glamour in the '70s. Regardless of origin, this is clearly a cookie that stands the test of time — both long- and short-term! This recipe makes a gigantic batch, and the dough can be chilled or frozen for later use. The cookies themselves, once baked, will also last forever in your refrigerator, and though they harden over time, that's actually a good thing (especially when dipped in coffee)!
6YZUi8XBl-P_dbZ2TJYx1RVa8ZL8_OLR23Ws6nSNsoQ
Ingredients:
3 1/2 cups flour
2 tsp baking soda
1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
1 cup confectioner's (powdered) sugar
1 cup butter at room temperature
1 large egg
1 tsp cinnamon
1 tsp ground cloves
1 tsp ground ginger
1 tsp anise seeds or extract
2 tbs maple or brown rice syrup
Advertisement
Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
Mix flour and baking soda and set aside. In a large bowl, mix butter and sugar until light and fluffy. This can be done without an electric mixer, but it's a lot harder (though a great arm workout).
5Z02EUaAVSl3oSV67lCNF5gC0S279RBEJChUVRrU-9c
ATQ2Wy1_toeFnCzega_zUViCCsrAX2dRjTI5YnqPzIk
Beat in egg, then all the spices, the anise seeds, and the syrup.
uOx60mbuSuH0sFNDraB-TNft4IE5qLu3jjT-dPzWizA
n9EE6Gvv-nRtEfkmP2W72I_ZxkMuRouwMZnA5ocwFVU
JkPA5tttACaXVsR9RNegupuMrYOF2UcJawzO6PoJ8-Y
Stir in the flour in parts, mixing with the electric mixer or with a fork, eventually forming into a ball of dough with your hands. If, after adding all the flour, the mixture is too dry to form a solid ball, add a splash of hot water.
Advertisement
r0JqtIU760NO3wG04CRpRKoIQsk--wQguXwIHXcvWTk
Wrap the dough ball and refrigerate for at least one hour. If you plan to save some of the dough for use in a later batch, this is the time to divide it.
3v18tvpT-iwa3exOIQfsGUwf_fn2Q_JBmfrlI_UjQ84
Remove the dough and divide into eight balls (or four, if you're using half of the original quantity). Carefully shape each ball into a long roll. Don't get discouraged if it crumbles — this is a fairly dry dough, just push it back together with your fingers as you roll it out to prevent cracking.
M2A0KgTMfISofbYVOsVxvomkE8p40LL1h5S_vQt53yA
p9KOFUvDlQrjBTBvUU9tClRhPW_TxksReQzZ1AwPhHs
Slice the roll into small pieces and form each piece into a ball.
n_81uZITFFdECqA2JXMHM0g6PnfcvpE_v3XUSCtkwog
Place about one inch apart on parchment paper. Bake for seven-10 minutes, until cookies are golden brown and come up from paper easily. Test with your finger to make sure cookies don't deform under pressure before removing from the oven.
vj43MEtNVX-C38ETyENyDqSOtO9l4XVoQznhukVwsAM
Remove cookies from oven and let cool slightly. While still warm, roll the cookies in a bowl of powdered sugar.
U15u-l5786GvtYF4Fava7oyE_NAGGWy0mJhh0NQiS2w
Eat your heart out...if you manage to go through a whole batch by yourself in under three weeks, then you are a true champion.
nPglUnBWYuu1s0w-l8UaMwa_VCD5ujIBu3TPeKO6fq4
Advertisement