Mystery Fragrance A

Christene Barberich, editor-in-chief: "It smells like an old, classic fragrance. It's a little sweet and powdery. There's amber in it, maybe. It smells kind of grandma-ish. It's very feminine and classic. I see a more conservative girl wearing this."

Neha Gandhi, deputy editor: "It smells kind of strong and chemical-y. I feel like I would probably not wear this — it's too aggressive."

Kristian Laliberte, senior editor: "I smell a little vanilla in here. It's a heavy scent. It's very luxurious — reminds me of a glamorous socialite. Actually, it reminds me of my mother."

Connie Wang, global editor: "It smells like the stuff my grandma would buy at the drugstore. That's to say, not so good. I think no one under the age of 50 should wear this — it's too powdery-smelling."

Annie Georgia Greenberg, New York editor: "I feel like I've smelled this before; it's a very generic perfume smell — like when I think of perfume, this is what I think of. It's flowery and a little powdery. I wouldn't wear this myself, but it's like a power perfume."