What's Going On With Trump's Plan To Ban Trans People From The Military?

Photo: Artur Widak/NurPhoto/Getty Images.
President Trump's tweets declaring transgender people unwelcome in the armed forces have plunged the Pentagon into a legal and moral quagmire, sparking a flurry of meetings to devise a new policy that could lead to hundreds of service members being discharged.
Months after officially allowing transgender troops to serve openly in the military, the department may be forced to throw out those who willingly came forward after being promised they'd be protected. A team of military lawyers has been pulled together to deal with the matter, Adm. Paul Zukunft, the Coast Guard commandant, revealed at the Center For Strategic and International Studies this week.
Advertisement
These lawyers are working with the White House to flesh out some of the issues, and they're bolstered by a Pentagon working group that had initially been set up to advance the implementation of the Obama administration's year-old repeal of a transgender ban.
Now, they must deal with whatever new post-tweet policy emerges, according to the officials, who weren't authorized to speak publicly on the matter and requested anonymity.
Pentagon chief spokeswoman Dana White confirmed that talks between the White House and the Pentagon to work out the details of a new transgender policy have begun. Although it's unclear what the result will be, the discussions illustrate that Trump's aides aren't writing off his three-tweet salvo last week as an isolated outburst but as guidance for an upheaval in one of the military's most sensitive equal rights questions.
Whatever the final policy, court challenges are likely. And the personnel, healthcare, and fairness issues sure to ensue may compel some soldiers, sailors, and others to hide their identities and live a lie to remain in the military.
It's a scenario that raises the specter of the now-defunct "don't ask, don't tell" policy that once governed LGBTQ members of the military. While the 1993 compromise banned LGBTQ people from serving, it essentially safeguarded their places in the ranks as long as they kept their identity hidden. More than 13,000 were discharged after the policy was enacted. While many others remained, they were forced to keep their sexuality in the closet.
Advertisement
Now, asks Sarah Warbelow, legal director for the Human Rights Campaign, "Are they going to go on a witch hunt?"
The Pentagon working group had been studying healthcare questions and how and when transgender people might be allowed to enlist. Now its members and the military's legal experts must contemplate forcing out transgender troops, including many who have served multiple combat tours.
If Trump stands by his tweet and the Pentagon is told to begin discharging transgender service members, officials must address several questions: Who would be thrown out? What type of discharge would they receive? How long of a grace period would they have before leaving?
There also is no uniform method of tracking transgender troops across the services. That raises another challenge. Will the Pentagon target service members who have already asked to have their sex changed in the personnel system? Or would the crackdown expand to anyone who simply sought counseling on the issue?
Warbelow questioned where the effort would end. People could be scrutinized for how they look or dress. For example, she suggested, could female troops be suspect for wearing clothing considered "too masculine?"
Trump's tweets last week were direct. He said the government won't accept or allow transgender individuals to serve "in any capacity" in the military.
Estimates of the number of transgender troops in the service vary widely. A study by The Williams Institute found there are about 15,500 transgender people in the military at the moment.
A Rand Corp. study estimated only 30 to 130 active duty troops out of a force of 1.3 million would seek transition-related healthcare each year. Costs could be $2.4 million to $8.4 million, it estimated — or an increase of healthcare costs by 0.04% to 0.13% annually.
Advertisement
The study found 19 other countries allow transgender people to serve openly in the military. "In no case was there any evidence of an effect on the operational effectiveness, operational readiness, or cohesion of the force," Rand said.
After Trump's tweets, Zukunft, the Coast Guard commandant, said, "the first thing we did is we reached out to all 13 members of the Coast Guard who have come out." But any reassurance Pentagon officials offered may prove hollow under a new policy.
Trump's pronouncement triggered bipartisan denunciations. Military and other officials described it as the latest example of Trump's administration struggling to translate the commander-in-chief's Twitter proclamations into actual policy. Until the Pentagon gets a new policy directive in writing, Gen. Joseph Dunford, the Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman, and other military leaders have said nothing will change.
Advertisement