Instagram Comparing Amy Schumer To Aphrodite Reminds Us Beauty Standards Aren't Universal

In April, Amy Schumer was included in Glamour's "Chic At Any Size" issue, which was tailored toward plus-size women. In an Instagram post critiquing this decision, she wrote, "Young girls seeing my body type thinking that is plus size? What are your thoughts? Mine are not cool glamour not glamourous."

Through this commentary, Schumer drew attention to a paradox we run up against when we celebrate women who are larger than beauty standards dictate: It shouldn't be notable that a woman is not a size zero. In fact, if Schumer's Instagram post is correct in stating that she wears between a six and an eight, she's smaller than the national average of size 14. When we characterize women who aren't stick-thin as unusual, we risk perpetuating these problematic standards.


A different post currently circulating around Instagram points out exactly why it doesn't make sense to portray women like Schumer as abnormal or brave to show their bodies. It displays the comedian alongside a statue of the ancient Greek goddess of love Aphrodite, once considered the pinnacle of beauty, and the two images bear some similarities. In ancient Greek culture, nobody would consider Amy Schumer plus-sized.

"So many women and young girls are shamed by the media and fashion industry for not having a flat stomach and not being a size zero. But look, the goddess of beauty is portrayed here with stomach rolls and doesn't have a perfectly smooth, toned body," wrote the creator of the viral image, who goes by @whitneyzombie on Instagram. Amy Schumer herself took notice of the image and shared it.


This comparison proves that beauty standards are not the same everywhere. It's only because of our narrow definitions of attractiveness and normalcy that either of these bodies is considered remarkable for not being size zero or having stomach rolls. And, again, they shouldn't be viewed this way. In another viral Instagram post, model Anna Victoria, who is known for her flat abs, reveals her own stomach rolls. It's just how gravity works.

We don't always acknowledge this, however— and it's nice to be reminded that there was a time when the bodies we consider bold to show off were once simply accepted as beautiful.
Advertisement

More from Body

Brittany Mostiller still remembers the moment when she realized that she couldn’t afford an abortion. “I didn’t know anything about this Hyde Amendment ...
Earlier this year, Lena Dunham was hospitalized to treat a ruptured ovarian cyst, unintentionally shedding light on an often ignored area of women's health...
If your eyes tend to glaze over at first mention of the latest Health Hack That Will Change Your Life, we can’t really blame you. Although we are literally...
Pregnant women get a lot of advice about motherhood, even when they don't ask for it. And in the first episode of Expecting, from Refinery29's comedy ...
We're in plus-size pool party heaven
Summer is over (for real). So it's time to face the facts: You're going to get a cold. Actually, you're probably going to get colds — plural. The average ...
The pelvic exam — complete with the stirrups and the speculum — isn't anyone's favorite thing about having a vagina. But it's really important because it's...
(Paid Content) Stress sweat is different from regular sweat in that it feeds off bacteria and causes odor. Then you start to think about it — producing ...
A few years ago, two Michigan urologists noticed a curious pattern among their patients: Upon returning from a Disney World vacation, patients would ...
It shouldn't be this complicated, all this body stuff: size discrimination, weight bias, the multi-factioned movement fighting to reverse it. At its core ...
On principle, I am skeptical of any internet health recommendation that has the word “challenge” tacked on to the end of it. These wellness fads come and...
Although he had been dead for decades, Jim Morrison said something a few years ago that shocked people. He wasn’t speaking from beyond the grave, but in ...
In April, I ran a story called “The Medium-Sized Woman Problem.” The “problem,” of course, was not the women themselves, but the way in which we frame ...
Jill Krause writes about all things mom, parenting, and relationships at her blog, Baby Rabies, and she has some words of advice for the non-pregnant ...