That's the premise of Two Night Stand, which arrives in theaters on September 26. The film's first trailer has just dropped, so you can go ahead and get a sneak peek of what looks to be one seriously cringeworthy sexual experience.
Analeigh Tipton and That Awkward Moment star Teller play the two hookup-ees, with Gossip Girl alum Jessica Szohr and rapper Kid Cudi in supporting roles. (Yeah, we got excited, too.)
After a night of no-strings-attached fun, Tipton and Teller find themselves housebound when a snowstorm strikes. Some might go back to bed or bust out the Scrabble board, but these two use the time to critique each other's sexual performances and delve into the finer points of dating.
Potential spoiler: We have a feeling that all this squabbling leads to them to suddenly fall in love, but that's only because we've seen, like, other romantic comedies.
Like this post? There's more. Get tons of celeb goodness, insider intel, movie and TV news, and more on the Refinery29 Entertainment Facebook page!