Is Your Fitness Tracker Lying?

IMG_0060_JessicaNashPhotographed By Jessica Nash.
Sporting an activity tracker has become a rite of passage for many fitness lovers. Of course, if you’re going to pony up the cash for a piece of fancy, wearable tech, you want it to work.
Unfortunately, researchers from Iowa State University found that your favorite fitness trackers are not so spot-on in terms of measuring the calories you burn throughout the day. The study, published in Medicine & Science in Sport & Exercise, compared data from eight different trackers. Researchers had 30 men and 30 women wear all of the devices during a 69-minute "workout" that involved 13 different types of activities, including running, Wii tennis, and playing on the computer. As a means of comparison, participants also wore a portable metabolic analyzer that measured their actual energy expenditure based on oxygen intake.
How did the trackers stack up? Researchers determined that the bands were “reasonably accurate,” with most calorie-burn readings registering between 10 and 15% of lab-tested stats. But, what we find most interesting is that the three top performers — BodyMedia FIT (9.3% error rating), Fitbit Zip (10.1% error rating), and Fitbit One (10.4% error rating) — are all designed to be worn either around your arm or at your hip, not at your wrist.
The forerunners are also priced close to $100, compared with the least accurate option, Basis Band, which retails at $199. “The devices have sufficient validity to provide consumers with a reasonable estimate of their physical activity behavior," says study co-author Gregory Welk, PhD, professor of kinesiology at the university. "But, the monitors will only help a person be physically active if they use the feedback to modify their behavior on a regular basis."
It’s also important to note that not everyone who sports a fitness tracker is focused on calorie expenditure — most monitors also track step count and sleep quality, providing helpful insight into your overall health and general activity level. Additionally, the devices used in this research aren’t the very-latest, souped-up models newly available on the market. But: "We are actually conducting another study this summer to test the newer versions of most of the devices, including the Fitbit Flex," Dr. Welk tells us.
Still, all this research data that's tracking data about data-trackers isn't just a tongue-twister; it also seems like a big step closer to creating the perfect model.
Below, the full rankings of fitness monitors from the study:
BodyMedia FIT (9.3% error rating)
Fitbit Zip (10.1% error rating)
Fitbit One (10.4% error rating)
Jawbone UP (12.2% error rating)
Actigraph (12.6% error rating)
Directlife (12.8% error rating)
Nike FuelBand (13.0% error rating)
Basis Band (23.5% error rating)

More from Fitness

If you've ever felt like you get more out of your workout while exercising with a partner, it's not just your imagination. According to a study published ...
I know the feeling — you're planning to exercise, but you get home after a long day and it just. Feels. Impossible. Maybe you can make yourself change into...
This article was originally published on November 20, 2015. In her own words, pole dancer and fitness trainer Roz "The Diva" Mays is where she is today by...
When it comes to rock climbing, an all-or-nothing approach is key
Sometimes getting motivated to exercise can be harder than the workout itself. That’s why it helps to think of your gym time as a middle school dance: ...
The benefits of yoga are constantly touted by fitness gurus and scientific researchers alike: practicing yoga has been linked to reducing stress, boosting ...
Working out's a LOT more fun when you can do it on your own terms, in your own crib, with your own tunes, and your own friends
(Paid Content) Normally, we celebrate getting into a fitness groove. It means that we've committed — on a pretty regular basis — to laying out workout ...
Ashley Graham is breaking barriers. She's the first plus-sized model to cover the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue and she's served as our workout ...
In a move so fitting that we can’t believe we haven’t seen it already, ASOS teamed up with running shoe company Saucony to create glitter running ...
If you ask us, no workout is complete without a killer playlist — and running is no exception. Whether you prefer the trails or the treadmill, the right ...
We may not all be able to keep up a daily diet of personal training, SoulCycle, and hot yoga. But there's a lot more to learn from celebrities' workout ...
Update: This story was previously published on Nov 21, 2015. Are you sitting down? Okay, take a minute to assess: Are you slouching in your seat? Are your...
Ah, the plank. Some version of it is used in virtually every type of fitness program, from CrossFit to calisthenics to yoga to pilates, and for good reason...