Why Gone Girl's New Ending Is A Big Letdown

gonegirl1Photo: via @20thCenturyFox.
Gone Girl was never supposed to be tied up simply. It is a story about love, murder, revenge, the media's treatment of the accused and the accuser. And, it raises a lot of ugly questions. (Like, what happens when the person you love is kind of truly horrible?) There is a reason that Gillian Flynn didn't give her book an easy ending.
So, when I learned Flynn wrote a new third act for the film adaptation I was disappointed. I was deeply affected (albeit, uncomfortably so) by the novel's tricky conclusion. And, I couldn't help but wonder, Why should the movie receive a different ending? Should a desire to appeal to the masses sacrifice the book's hard truths? These nasty, broken realizations end up sticking with the reader — for better or worse — long after the last page has been turned. Don't filmgoers deserve the same?
When it comes to entertainment (books, movies, TV shows), we often seek out easily understood resolutions. But, sometimes an unsettling ending is exactly what makes a compelling story. (See: Chinatown, Requiem For A Dream, heck, even Titanic.) While I didn't immediately like the ending of the book, it still gives me lingering, conflicted thoughts. Every time I see Gone Girl mentioned in a headline, the unsettling feeling returns, which is a hallmark of a good story. And, I knew it would be interesting to see how the events unfolded onscreen.
Seeing Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike bring Nick and Amy to life will add another dimension to the already very complex characters. But, it's disappointing they are missing the chance to showcase their strengths as they wrangle with the conflicting emotions of the last scenes of the story. If anything, the movie could have enhanced the reading of the book, in the same way it did with The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo. The first act caught our attention; the second kept us reading; but the third act is what made the book linger. It made Gone Girl more than just another book we read. Hopefully, the movie, despite the new ending, will still have the same impact.

More from Movies

As a former dancer, there are few things that bring me more joy than dance movies. You needn't have grown up at the barre to love and appreciate films in ...
In February of 2016, Emily Blunt was in the middle of filming Girl On The Train, a psychological thriller. While on-set, Blunt had a big secret: she was ...
After deciding to give Cinderella, Beauty and The Beast, The Jungle Book, and possibly Mulan the live action treatment, Disney has announced that yet ...
The 1960s never seemed creepier than in Rose McGowan’s haunting short film, Dawn (2014). McGowan, whose long acting résumé includes roles on TV megahits ...
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them is easily one of the most highly-anticipated movies of the year, but we still have just over a month before Newt ...
How to describe a Tim Burton movie? The writer, director, producer, and illustrator has been sharing his visions of love, children, fear, and beauty with ...
In the upcoming indie sci-fi flick Crossbreed, Vivica A. Fox will play a president who sends war veterans on a mission to retrieve an alien whose DNA is ...
Have you ever re-watched an old movie and cringed? Maybe you were watching Breakfast at Tiffany's and Mickey Rooney's overtly racist Asian stereotype ...
A few months ago, I found myself riveted by an appearance Melissa Harris-Perry made on Real Time With Bill Maher. Harris-Perry had recently left her show...
The miracle and the curse of Netflix are one and the same: There is so much damn stuff to watch. In fact, if you're not sure exactly what you're looking ...
As if winning an Oscar wasn't enough, actress Lupita Nyong'o just proved that she has another talent under her belt: freestyle rapping. The 33-year-old ...
There are few movies that just beg to be parodied more than Fifty Shades of Grey. But High School Musical comes pretty darn close. In case you haven't ...
This month, many 15-year-olds are just getting in the back-to-school swing of things. But Auli'i Cravalho's schedule is a little bit different: The teen ...
Growing up is hard to do. Before "adulting" — that is, clumsily impersonating our role models and pretending we have our lives together — became a buzzword...