Why Did Audiences Laugh At Divergent's Rape Scene?

Divergent_embed1Photo: Courtesy of Summit Entertainment.
From Gone with the Wind to A Walk to Remember (or even The Virgin Daughters), women in film are all too often portrayed as safeguarding their precious virginity against an army of lustful young men, with little discussion of what sex means emotionally and physically for both parties. It's a common theme and a boring one. So, in a way, it's heartening that Divergent tried to take on sexuality, consent, and female empowerment all in one scene — that's quite a can of worms for a film with such sweeping reach. But, it ended up leaving the audience feeling a mixture of incredulity and discomfort and then literally laughing out loud. So, what made this moment feel both phony and disturbingly out of place?
Advertisement
The scene in question features heroine Tris experiencing attempted rape at the hands of her boyfriend, Four, during a mental simulation in which she's forced to face her worst fear. It's unique to the script, but not entirely without some grounding in the text. Tris, who comes from the post-apocalyptic faction that raises children with such extreme selflessness that they are forbidden to look in the mirror for too long, has a fear of intimacy. She's afraid of wanting someone or something, wary of emotional closeness and desire for pleasure of any kind — that's not necessarily connected to sex.
The book also includes an attack on Tris by several masked men with clearly sexual undertones that aren't present in the movie. Without that, the only other mention of her fear of intimacy is her interruption of a sunset makeout sesh with, "I don't want to go too fast." That, in particular, had viewers (at least the cynical, NYC kind) cracking up.
Because the film provides next to no context for Tris' fear, the rape scene — beyond just being a gratuitous add-on — does a disservice both to our understanding of what constitutes rape, and how female sexuality is depicted in media. (Before you remind us that movies don't need to be lessons for young people, consider that kids still in middle school made up a sizable chunk of ticket sales.)
It's not that there's something wrong with depicting a young woman fighting back against an aggressor, or making decisions about her own sexuality. Those are good things, and viewers of all ages could benefit from more filmmakers daring to go there.
divergent_embed2Photo: Courtesy of Summit Entertainment.
Advertisement
Tris voicing her reticence to have sex could've been a really progressive model for young couples to talk about taking that step. Instead, we get a breathless, Sandra Dee moment, and her hesitation is somehow expanded into a deeply rooted fear of rape. Aside from being a bizarre leap in the plot, this leaves no middle ground between abstinence and rape. It takes an equal, respectful partnership and forces it into a painfully retro vision of gender identity in which the girl is afraid, and the boy is predatory — a stereotype that doesn't give nearly enough credit to young girls' understanding of their own developing sexuality.
It would make sense that a 16-year-old Tris wants to approach sex cautiously in her first relationship, especially since the world is basically about to explode into a million crazy pieces. In the book, both characters are nervous, they're both virgins, and they both want each other. In the film, Four becomes needlessly aggressive. This addition is made even more awkward by the well-cast chemistry between Shailene Woodley and Theo James. We enjoy watching them make out, and can't deny the intensity of their smooches. Given that, Tris' statement that she doesn't want to go too fast feels shoe-horned in. It's fine in principle. It's not fine when the only followup scene involves rape, effectively showing physical violence to be a logical reaction to her reluctance. Everything else we know about these characters — both in the book and the movie — suggests that they are on on the same level, approaching sex with a realistic combination of nervousness and longing.
It's not exactly a surprise that a YA movie's attempt at depicting the complexities of sexuality, female empowerment, and sexual assault would be so fumbling. In fact, it's pretty standard for the genre. Twilight did it in a particularly egregious way, literally conflating premarital sex with the loss of basic humanity. In that iteration, Edward's the breathless, demure one — Bella is interested in sex, but he's protecting her from it, because she is a delicate flower and thus in need of his sage male guidance.
As we've seen with The Hunger Games before, literature and films for young adults have the potential to be both massively influential and truly worthwhile for a variety of viewers. Divergent makes a strong statement about self-actualization and identity, but it would've differentiated itself hugely from competitors by addressing sexuality in an equally progressive way. Because, let's face it, in a post-apocalyptic world that throws hundreds of teenagers together in largely unsupervised, co-ed dormitories, it's going to come up sooner or later.
Advertisement

More from Movies

In May of 2016, Amber Heard and Johnny Depp announced their divorce after being married for 15 months. The 53-year-old actor and 30-year-old actress did ...
Hey dudes and dudettes. As they say in stoner movies: It’s 4:20 somewhere — a.k.a. the unofficial official time of day to spark a blunt, hit the bong, toke...
Filmmaker Tim Burton is known for his fantastically weird movies — The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993), Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street...
A few months ago, I found myself riveted by an appearance Melissa Harris-Perry made on Real Time With Bill Maher. Harris-Perry had recently left her show...
It’s pretty obvious that movie and television characters don’t look the way most of us do, and that it's a problem. But rarely do we actually talk about ...
Dear fans of the book The Girl on the Train: I have good news for you. Director Tate Taylor, the book's author Paula Hawkins, and screenwriter Erin ...
Sex scenes, we've seen a few. The first times that seldom bear resemblance to anyone's real first time. The quick-my-wife-is-out-of-town humpfests that ...
We are not robots. We feel things. We can't survive on comedic bromances and CGI-ed action sequences alone. We like our joy, but we need our sadness, too. ...
Shia LaBeouf's performance in American Honey proves that he's not the weirdo we all pegged him to be. Perhaps, it's the opposite — maybe it's his ability...
As a former dancer, there are few things that bring me more joy than dance movies. You needn't have grown up at the barre to love and appreciate films in ...
In February of 2016, Emily Blunt was in the middle of filming Girl On The Train, a psychological thriller. While on-set, Blunt had a big secret: she was ...
After deciding to give Cinderella, Beauty and The Beast, The Jungle Book, and possibly Mulan the live action treatment, Disney has announced that yet ...
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them is easily one of the most highly-anticipated movies of the year, but we still have just over a month before Newt ...
How to describe a Tim Burton movie? The writer, director, producer, and illustrator has been sharing his visions of love, children, fear, and beauty with ...