Knockoff Cosmetics: Necessary, Evil, Or Both?

When it comes to our beloved beauty products, we put quality above all else. It doesn't matter if it's from Walgreens or Barneys: If it works well, we need it. That said, eerily similar products can come with shockingly different price tags. So, we can't help but wonder: How much of a steep price is pretty marketing, and how much of it is actual quality?
In a piece on The New York Times, the issue of copycatting — cheapie beauty brands creating affordable versions of luxury makeup — is addressed at length. “Imitation has become rampant in the cosmetics industry,” Alix Strauss writes, explaining a very familiar pattern: The “hot,” expensive products set the trends, and then mass-marketing companies create affordable versions for the people.
The underlying assumption in the Times is that luxury brands are trendsetters. Of course, that's not always the case, and the argument can quickly turn into a chicken-or-egg situation. Regardless, the main issue with copycatting is it takes business away from the company that invented the original product — as is the case in all industries. However, we like to think that imitation is necessary in a business that thrives on creativity and newness. Without the pressure to create innovative, new products, beauty would come to a standstill, and that would make our jobs, in particular, pretty boring.
And, honestly, we’re not mad at drugstore brands for making prestige concepts more accessible. While we love the feeling of pampering ourselves, beauty shouldn’t be an exclusive club. That’s one of our favorite things about it — a well-drawn cat-eye knows no economic bounds. (The New York Times)
knockoffs openerPhoto: Via The New York Times.


Like this post? There's more. Get tons of beauty tips, tutorials, and news on the Refinery29 Beauty Facebook page!

More from Makeup

Contouring can, as we've shown before, look scary. But, enhancing your cheekbones or jawline doesn't have to be frightening — or require the skill of a ...
Leather jackets, new jeans, cozy sweaters — we’re all for building up our fall wardrobes around this time of year, but we also like to give a little love ...
If you're guilty of perennially picking at your pimples (try saying that 10 times fast) or you've battled cystic bumps since your teenage years, chances ...
When I was eight years old, I knew nothing about makeup. Did that stop me from collecting palette upon palette of colorful shadows and sparkly tubes of ...
Even though the last day of summer isn't technically until September 22, we're already starting to feel the cozy embrace of fall. Our sweaters are ...
Anyone who has been to Sprinkles knows its cupcakes are so delicious that you wish you could taste them all the time. Now, you can — or at least you can ...
Attention royal family fans: There's a new Charlotte Tilbury lipstick in town and it's regal AF
(Paid Content) Some beauty trends from decades past always manage to circle back — they’re just too good to keep locked away in a previous era! Now you can...
“I love cleaning my makeup brushes,” said no one, ever. Okay fine, some people do get great satisfaction from washing their beauty tools, but we're not ...
Pat McGrath posted three photos from the Versace fashion show to Instagram that tease a new product she's working on. The first shows Gigi Hadid with ...
Every morning, before I steep my morning tea, I scroll through my Instagram feed taking note of all the standout swatches, 60-second videos, and ...
Here's the good news about brown eyes: They're easy to play up, since brown is a mix of the primary colors. This most-common of eye colors is a gorgeous ...
I don't consider myself a vain person, but when I think of my #goals, having Cate Blanchett levels of skin perfection is right there at the tippy-top. Well...
Base makeup is one of those notoriously hard beauty products to shop for. Like picking out jeans or bras, the process takes time, commitment, and patience...