Not Again: "Tribal Warriors" At Nicholas K

As much as the Internet may like to rave about over-sensitivity, when it comes to cultural appropriation, the difference between offensive stereotyping and sensitive, artful homage is primarily one of laziness. That difference was clearer than ever at the most recent Nicholas K. show at NYFW.
niK2Photo: MCV Photo.
Advertisement
According to a press release we received from the brand, models were sent down the runway in a "modern tribal warrior" makeup look (quotes are actually theirs, oddly enough) for a show that was "heavily influenced by Native American tribal themes." Ah, yes. "Tribal themes." All those Native Americans, with their tribes, and their themes — what a wonderfully specific, carefully-researched reference to make at Fashion Week, where cultures can be condensed and minimized for the sake of "trend."
See, the problem here isn't even necessarily that Native American cultural imagery — or any cultural imagery, for that matter — cannot inspire or be referenced by a person outside of that culture. If a designer sees something he or she finds beautiful, and wants to integrate that theme into a collection or a show after having made at least a minimal effort to learn about the origin of the imagery or the cultural context, that's generally not a problem.
Click through to the next page to read on (and see more photographic evidence).
NiK1Photo: MCV Photo.
Alexander McQueen did something of the sort, albeit with a much more unsettling commentary on sociopolitical issues, in his groundbreaking Highland Rape collection. But, sending a bunch of models down the runway with headbands, feathers, and some reddish "sunburned" eye makeup and then calling it "tribal" is not an example of homage. It's just lazy, and it further promotes the stereotype that all Native Americans share one culture that is primarily based on the wearing of headdresses.
Advertisement
The Kunz siblings behind the brand grew up in Tucson, near an Apache reservation, so we'd expect to see something a tad more nuanced. Style.com writes about the show that "Native American themes can go politically incorrect fast, but the Kunzes' closeness to the subject kept it in check." On the contrary, we'd argue that being "close" to a culture doesn't give you a free pass to haphazardly throw it around whenever and however you feel like it; rather, it gives you a responsibility to depict said culture in a way that is interesting, innovative, and true to life. That's all the more important in an industry that makes the same mistakes over and over again when it comes to Native American cultural appropriation. So, is this the most blasphemous, offensive, horrible thing on Earth? No. It's not even the most offensive representation of Native Americans we've seen. But it is a big disappointment, and it feels like a missed opportunity to demonstrate how cross-cultural communication can be valuable and inspiring.
Advertisement

More from New York

In New York City, fitness studios are like restaurants: you have your go-tos, the top-reviewed places you're willing to spend your dollars on, the hidden ...
In a city of never-ending menus and food trends, it can be hard to figure out the next best brunch spot, lunchtime haunt, or recipe to master. However, all...
It’s called the city that never sleeps for a reason. On any night of the week, New Yorkers are enjoying a cocktail, a dance party, a special meal, a ...
Just because you aren't wearing "short-shorts" doesn't mean your dress qualifies as office-and-everywhere appropriate. In fact, a short dress can be more ...
This may be news to you, but living in New York is kind of expensive. But, while it may always be the land of $17 cocktails and unmentionable rents, the ...
We won't call this list definitive, because rooftops are, after all, all about spontaneity. And, with three summer months to get your toes wet (literally ...
Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to eat roasted guinea pig in Flushing, Queens. Oh, is that not how the Statue of Liberty poem ...
(Paid Content) When a movie like Disney's Queen of Katwe comes out, you know award season is upon us. The inspiring new film has all the makings of an ...
The West Village may get all the attention as the fancy foodie haven of New York City, but that’s just fine for the East Village. All that means is that ...
Appetizers are nice and entrées are essential, but we adore dessert. For real — we feel about ice cream and cookies and brownies the way Liz Lemon feels ...
The only thing more depressing than the end of summer is the number of days between now and the next long weekend. We know: All you want is to sit by a ...
The Lower East Side may be best known to you as the home of rowdy, rollicking nightlife, but that adventure extends to the food scene as well. Restaurants ...
Is there anything better on a Saturday afternoon than a spicy Bloody Mary and some simple — but delicious — bacon and eggs? Didn't think so. Brunch is the ...
You've probably heard about how gritty Soho was back in the '70s and '80s, when artists flocked to the downtown 'hood in search of affordable living and ...